When I was younger, I described myself as a complementarian, but was willing to be called a patriarchalist. Now I commend biblical patriarchy, but I’m willing to be called a complementarian in the right contexts. It’s from that perspective that I address the question of complementarianism’s future.
Complementarianism is the belief that men and women are equal in being, dignity, and value, but distinct and complementary in role and responsibility. The Danvers Statement (1988) establishes the basic convictions of complementarians. The Nashville Statement (2017) might be thought of as an extension and application of complementarian principles to new challenges (such as transgenderism), but it also revealed fault lines within the camp between what came to be called “thin/soft complementarians” and “thick/hard complementarians.”
The term was coined in the 1980s as a way of recovering the biblical teaching on manhood and womanhood. In that sense, complementarianism claimed to reflect the traditional biblical teaching in the face of modern feminism. At the same time, complementarians were keen to differentiate in two different directions, not just one. On the one hand, they rejected novel egalitarian interpretations of the biblical text. But they were also keen to differentiate from “hierarchicalist” views of the relation between men and women. This two-fold differentiation frequently led to a “third way” rhetorical positioning between egalitarianism on one side and patriarchy on the other.
Complementarianism’s origin story leaves it susceptible to a number of weaknesses. First, because the occasion for the recovery was the rise of egalitarianism in evangelical denominations, it is often sensitive to egalitarian critiques of traditional churches and will at times accept the egalitarian framing of patriarchal societies as systematically oppressive. The “Third Way” rhetorical positioning lends itself to emphasizing equal and opposite dangers on each side, rather than rhetorically pressing on the true threat. For while there are abusive patriarchal societies in the world (such as those in traditional Islamic nations), the overwhelming threat to biblical manhood and womanhood in the West is egalitarianism and feminism.
Second, because early complementarians were primarily animated by issues affecting the home and church, there was less interest, energy, and unity when it came to applying their convictions to society as a whole. This gap leaves complementarians divided when it comes to addressing wider culture issues. It also lends itself to the cultivation of complementarian ghettos in the midst of a “longhoused” society.
Finally, the combination of the neologism “complementarianism” and the emphasis on biblical manhood and womanhood runs the risk of turning complementarianism into an ideology imposed upon nature, rather than a biblical stewardship of nature. As evidence for this danger, many “soft complementarians” have effectively adopted a modern egalitarian anthropology and resist the full slide into feminism only because of a handful of verses in Paul’s letters.
In light of this history and these dangers, what is the way forward? First, we must continue to underscore that Scripture and nature speak with one voice.[1] The facts of creation revealed in Scripture give rise to facts of nature evident to all men (though suppressed in unrighteousness, like many aspects of God’s revelation).
More than that, we must cheerfully and forthrightly assert that, biblically speaking, male headship is a fact, not a command. It’s an indicative, not an imperative.[2] This fact is manifest first in the home, then in the church by divine law, and then in society as a normal and natural outworking of God’s design in creation. In the long run, patriarchy is inevitable and unavoidable. It will either be a faithful and biblical patriarchy, a tyrannical patriarchy (such as found in Islam), or a sniveling patriarchy steered and manipulated by the Longhouse. Even our present egalitarian society shows the marks of a demented patriarchy, as feminism reaches its terminus in the trans-insanity, in which sinful and toxic female empathy[3] leads to civilizational suicide.
Second, as we preach Scripture and point to nature, we must assume the center. No defensive crouch that flinches in the face of feminist fury. Complementarians must unapologetically and publicly embrace that a society ruled by women is fundamentally sick. Indeed, Scripture asserts that female rule is a sign of divine judgment (Isa 3:12).
And we must do both of these in the face of feminist lies. There’s the accusation, complete with actors playing dress-up, that we want to enact The Handmaid’s Tale, that we want our wives to be barefoot, pregnant in the kitchen, making sourdough. Of course, this is a gross slander. We are more than happy for our wives to wear shoes as they make the sourdough.
But more than this, many of the accusations are a type of confession. The only people today who want to turn women into incubators are those who celebrate homosexuals renting wombs from vulnerable women and purchasing babies via unregulated surrogacy.
Third, complementarians must stop catering to women as an interest group to be placated. Too many ostensibly complementarian churches are filled with constant pressure and agitation to get more women “up front” or “in the room where it happens.” The push for “functional female officers,” whether among Presbyterians or Baptists, is a sign of how far the feminist rot has spread.
Instead, we must cultivate Christian communities where no such pressure exists, because women are too busy doing the glorious, glad-hearted, and meaningful work of making a productive household. Indeed, the recovery of the fruitful household is one of the central needs of Western Civilization, and those who gladly embrace male headship must also celebrate that Woman is the glory of Man, and that central to that glory is the bearing and raising of children, as well as knitting communities together with her hospitality, wisdom, and service.
Male headship is inevitable. So is female gloryhood. Men will rule, either as noble princes or wicked tyrants. Society will elevate women, either as prostitutes and celebrities, or as wives and mothers. Whether you call it complementarianism or patriarchy, this is the world that God made and that Christ is redeeming. May the Spirit give us the grace to live faithfully within it.
[1] Joe Rigney, “With One Voice: Scripture and Nature for Ethics and Discipleship,” Eikon: A Journal for Biblical Anthropology 1.1 (Spring 2019): 26–37.
[2] Joe Rigney, “Indicatives, Imperatives, and Applications: Reflections on Natural, Biblical, and Cultural Complementarianism,” Eikon: A Journal for Biblical Anthropology 4.1 (Spring 2022): 28–36.
[3] Joe Rigney, Leadership and The Sin of Empathy: Compassion and Its Counterfeits: A Christian Guide to Discernment, Emotional Manipulation, Boundaries and False Compassion (Moscow, ID: Canon Press, 2025).
Share This Article




