11.17.2026. — Articles

A New Third Way

by Aaron Renn

Complementarianism is a theology that will pass along with the Boomers who championed and helped create it.

To unpack that, we must first say what complementarianism is. Some say that it is merely the belief that God has ordained separate roles for men and women in the home and the church, and thus belongs to a theological tradition as old as the church. Others might point to the Danvers Statement, the 1987 confessional document issued by the Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood.

But complementarianism as understood and practiced today is best seen as a new, third way, biblicist response to Second Wave Feminism, one that was developed during the 1970s through to the early 1990s.

The developers of complementarianism themselves saw it as a response to Second Wave Feminism. The primary book expounding it was Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood (RBMW), published in 1991 and edited by John Piper and Wayne Grudem. It was subtitled A Response to Evangelical Feminism. In his own telling, Grudem describes getting interested in gender theology through word studies rebutting the feminist interpretation of the Greek word kephalē, usually translated as “head.”[1]

It also described itself as a third way position. In addition to rejecting evangelical feminism, which affirmed egalitarian gender roles, its creators also explicitly rejected the American gender roles and theology of the pre-feminist era. Piper wrote in RBMW, “Our vision is not entirely the same as ‘a traditional view.’ We affirm that the evangelical feminist movement has pointed out many selfish and hurtful practices that have previously gone unquestioned.” Tim and Kathy Keller, among the most widely influential complementarians, wrote in a white paper on women in ministry, “The biblical pattern of headship is neither the traditional nor the feminist.”[2]

Whether intentionally or not, this third way approach applied a biblicist method. Because various Bible passages speak specifically to a male only pastorate and the husband as the head of the wife, these roles were affirmed. But complementarianism spoke very little about related areas beyond that. The Danvers Statement, for example, dealt explicitly only with these two issues, and otherwise stressed the equality of men and women before God and as being created in the image of God.

As a result, the Danvers Statement, and complementarianism generally, were anthropologically light. That is to say, while acknowledging differences between men and women, complementarianism speaks much more about what those differences are not than what they are. RBMW says, “Men and women as God created them are different in hundreds of ways.” Ok, but what are those differences? The book doesn’t tell us. By contrast, various complementarians have repeatedly provided examples of cases where women are superior to men as to what seem to be obvious qualifications for a particular role. The Kellers explicitly denied that the Bible says men are better equipped by nature for leadership in the home.[3] The ordinary evangelical might be justified in concluding that complementarian authorities intend to say that God did not create men as more suitable to certain roles by nature, but merely assigned them by fiat.

This biblicist, anthropology-lite approach leads to a default assumption that whatever roles not explicitly barred to women by Scripture are permitted. Kathy Keller formulated this as, “Anything that an unordained man is allowed to do, a woman is also allowed to do.”[4] While not all complementarians have a view as thin as this, the general tendency is toward a feminist-inflected view of women’s roles. (John Piper is a rare exception in saying women should also not serve in roles like military combat or when they hold “personal and directive”[5] authority over men).

What’s more, complementarianism could be seen as effectively an acceptance of Second Wave Feminism but for areas where it explicitly came into conflict with Scripture. As we saw above, the developers of complementarianism agreed with many feminist complaints. For example, the Danvers Statement says, without substantiation, that there was an “upsurge of physical and emotional abuse in the family.”

Complementarian theology also redefines headship to all but strip it of authority, while amplifying the husband’s responsibility for every negative thing in the household in addition to his responsibility to sacrifice everything in order to serve his wife and children. This is the “servant leader,” copying a term coined in 1970 by management consultant Robert Greenleaf.[6] In fact, complementarianism defines manhood almost entirely in terms of man’s relationship with his wife and children.

As an example of how complementarians tie themselves into pretzels to avoid saying anything to offend feminist sensibilities, John Piper, in his multiple essays criticizing women in military combat roles, never says men are better suited for those positions, and blames women being admitted to them entirely on male cowardice.[7]

My assessment of what was emerging as complementarianism is largely validated by renowned sociologist James Davison Hunter in his 1987 academic book Evangelicalism: The Coming Generation. He notes its newness, saying “That this model is historically unique there is little doubt.” He also describes its teaching as “doublespeak” in which hierarchy is affirmed in principle while denied in practice.

Complementarianism is a deeply flawed system, created and promoted largely by Silent Generation and Boomer figures — Piper, Grudem, and the Kellers are all Boomers — to respond to the specific cultural currents of the 1970s and 80s. It is likely to prove untenable in the long term because cultural conditions continue to change, and generational transition will eliminate those for whom complementarianism resonates.

Any viable replacement must be based in anthropology, that is, it must be based in creation order consistent with Scripture, rather than a narrow biblicism. And it must be defined by what it believes to be true rather than as a reactive system defined by what it is against. Most likely such an approach will not be created until the passage of the Boomer generation is complete.

[1] Wayne Grudem, “Personal Reflections on the History of CBMW and the State of the Gender Debate,” Journal on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, 14.1 (Spring 2009):…. , Issue 1, Spring 2009.

[2] Tim Keller and Kathy Keller, “Women and Ministry,” Redeemer Presbyterian Church, November 1989.

[3] Keller, “Women and Ministry.”

[4] Kathy Keller,  Jesus, Justice, and Gender Roles: A Case for Gender Roles in Ministry (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2012), 21.

[5] Piper, John, “Should Women Be Police Officers?”, Desiring God, August 13, 2015.

[6] The term is generally traced to Greenleaf’s 1970 essay, “The Servant as Leader.”

[7] See his Desiring God essays, “Co-ed Combat and Cultural Cowardice” (November 2, 2007), “More on Women in Combat” (November 4, 2007), and “The Folly of Men Arming Women for Combat” (January 6, 2014).

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Share This Article

  • Cracked earth landscape under a dramatic sunset sky

    A New Third Way

    By Aaron Renn

  • green leaf tree under sun set

    The Inevitability of Patriarchy

    By Joe Rigney

  • aerial photography of river between mountains

    A Tale of Two Complementarianisms

    By Doug Ponder

View All Articles
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
Click Here Click Here
Malcare WordPress Security