Modernity has done everything in its power to rid Western culture of religion, which ultimately means it has exhausted itself in uprooting the Christian pillars of our civilization. While operating on the assumption that religion is a psychological construct to be studied as a mere social phenomenon, the modernist assumed that man is inherently irreligious. And to the extent that man was intrinsically religious, his religiosity was deemed a liability to his judgement needing correction according to the enlightened dictates of human reason.
This demythologizing process has become the West’s operating philosophy, leading to the rejection of the biblical idea that man was created by God and that God speaks to man. This rejection in the West’s fundamental philosophy left man to find truth by his own light— whether by his own reason or empirical observations — if he was to find it at all. With God having long been removed from the equation — there was nothing left but for man to exalt himself.
The fool says there is no God
There is no doubt that the sages of modernity succeeded in convincing many that religion is an optional human experience, but in doing so they have unwittingly traded traditional religion for a new one — a religion of the self. Atheism, it turns out, is no atheism at all. For the modern man has simply replaced God’s authority with his own. His worship, therefore, is not theistic in the traditional sense, but is directed inward towards himself — a kind of MeTheism. While the modern person may deny his own religiosity and thereby reject the notion there has been any sort of religious replacement — it has nevertheless occurred.
This replacement is inescapable because religion is inescapable. As John Calvin wrote, “There is within the human mind, and indeed by natural instinct, an awareness of divinity.”[1] This awareness of God is evident, Calvin observed, in every culture:
Yet there is, as the eminent pagan [Cicero] says, no nation so barbarous, no people so savage, that they have not a deep seated conviction that there is a God. And they who in other aspects of life seem least to differ from brutes still continue to retain some seed of religion. So deeply does the common conception occupy the minds of all, so tenaciously does it inhere in the hearts of all! Therefore, since from the beginning of the world there has been no region, no city, in short, no household, that could do without religion, there lies in this a tacit confession of a sense of deity inscribed in the hearts of all.[2]
Calvin was right, and not simply because his assertion passes the test of experience. The Apostle Paul grounds religiosity in the fact that God exists and man knows it. As Paul wrote to the Romans,
For although they knew God, they did not honor him as God or give thanks to him, but they became futile in their thinking, and their foolish hearts were darkened. Claiming to be wise, they became fools, and exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images resembling mortal men and birds and animals and creeping things (Rom 1:21–23, ESV).
Mankind was created for communion with God. So when man refuses to worship the one for whom he was made, he directs his worship elsewhere. The Bible calls this idolatry. There is a great irony, however, in modernity’s claim of atheism, which has led to the exaltation of the self. Paul charges those who exchange the worship of the Triune God for false gods with foolishness and futility. But modern man is doubly foolish, for not only does he not worship the one true God, he’s deluded himself into thinking there is no God at all! But, in reality, he’s put himself in the place of God. In doing so, he’s become utterly futile and foolish in his thinking.
The autonomous self
Bereft of any divine (and therefore objective) source of truth and authority, man is left to define his own existence. While this sounds like freedom to modern ears, it turns out to be both destructive and tyrannical. Scripture teaches that man finds freedom and flourishing in obedience to God’s revealed will, but finds enslavement, suffering, and death when following his own. Through submitting to Christ, man is set free from the penalty and power of sin to pursue righteousness that leads to blessedness. The blessed man, the psalmist says, delights in the law of the Lord and makes it his constant meditation. This man is like a tree planted near water, full of fruitfulness and life. But those who reject God’s word are akin to wind-tossed chaff. Their end is destruction (Psa 1:2–4, 6).
But the religion of the self teaches a different doctrine — one that is new in some forms but in the end is the same teaching of the Garden serpent. The religion of the self catechizes in self-expression, self-affirmation, self-love, and self-care. It speaks of “your truth” and “my truth,” both to insulate from criticism and to preserve self-esteem, but also because in the absence of a Creator there is no Truth. Consequently, we are each free to construct the world in our own image. In such a world, the good life is found through self-actualization — becoming who you most deeply feel and think yourself to be.
Thus, central to the religion of self is the ability to determine who and what we are. This self-definition pretends to be man’s greatest freedom that leads to man’s ultimate sense of fulfillment. To take away this ability for self-actualization would amount to a direct attack on human dignity as it would deprive individuals of their fundamental right to define their own existence.
This religion of the self has manifested and morphed through various phases, visible most particularly through the sexual revolution. To give but a brief outline, feminism’s dismantling of gender roles supposedly liberated women’s sense of self from “the patriarchy,” which had “enslaved” women to motherhood, homemaking, and various nurturing vocations. The gradual acceptance of free-range fornication set the self free from the religious boundaries of marriage that previously suppressed the self’s gratification through sexual expression. And speaking of marriage, no-fault divorce helped husbands and wives more conveniently gain freedom from nuptial vows they no longer desired to fulfill.
Reproductive technologies and the widespread legalization of abortion further freed the self from the natural consequences of sexual intimacy. Via contraception, men and women were at liberty to have sex without a resulting progeny. With such freedom, sexual partners were no longer obliged to consider marriage as the exclusive context for sexuality, nor were they bound by the laws of nature which would — in the natural course of things — make them responsible for children. And, in the event that a child would be born, the woman’s right to “bodily autonomy” — the autonomy of the self — demanded that she be able to kill (“abort”) her child were it deemed to pose any inconvenience to the achievement of her self-fulfillment. In modernity, therefore, man is no longer subject to religious scruples, traditional institutions, and social obligation, but rises above them to pursue the authentic self.
The reign of the autonomous self came into full bloom with the arrival of so-called “same-sex marriage.” This new legal definition of marriage legitimized homosexuality by standing athwart human history to free same-sex couples from the repressive and passé norms of “traditional” marriage.[3] Free from these imposed limitations, same-sex couples gained the liberty to fulfill their sexual and romantic desires in a government-recognized union. Protests to the contrary were a threat to this dignity-conferring freedom.
But the religion of the self reached its pinnacle with the widespread acceptance of transgenderism, which unshackled the individual from the hegemonic binaries that prevented true self-expression. In transgender theory, gender is a mere social construct, having no direct connection to one’s sex. One’s gender-identity is, then, inherently subjective. The result is that individuals are free to choose (for himself, herself, theyself?) their gender, thereby assuming the individual authority to declare what a man or woman is. Thus the self is sovereign over gender. In the end, modern man has exalted the self as the sole determiner of what is good, true, and beautiful. And the self, according to his own subjective sense of these things, decides who and what he will be. The individual is therefore morally subject to no one but himself.
The tyrannical self
Despite the new religion’s success in achieving societal acceptance, it has not and will not be able to make good on its promises. For its declaration of liberation and autonomy leads ironically to a particular form of tyranny. This autotalitarianism — the tyranny of the self — enslaves people to their own desires and imaginations. The sovereign self turns out to be a hard task master. Subject to its own whims and fancies, it is subjugated to its most base lusts, since the greatest good is found in actualizing one’s longings and desires wherever they lead. The only brakes are internal, leaving no room for objective clarity and guardrails. As one’s own reference point, man finds himself in an endless maze of self-creation and discovery. Left to the capriciousness of his feelings, the individual looks inward for direction. But his map is a labyrinth of ever-changing desire, discontentedness, and inner-conflict. Due to his rejection of divine revelation, the self, while sovereign, does not truly know who (or whose) he is. He also cannot even know why he exists, meaning he can’t provide objective grounds for knowing his ultimate purpose in life — though he longs to know it.
In this way the religion of the self is ultimately cruel. It promises freedom, but for what? Its self-revelational epistemology provides no foundations on which to build and no destination towards which to sail. Under these conditions the self is far from liberating, but is instead oppressive. It asks for bricks, but gives no straw. It demands to be happy but on its own cannot meet its own demand.
And our culture reflects this. We are chronically depressed, anxious, lonely, and suicidal. We are dependent on drugs — both illicit and pharmaceutical — addicted to alcohol, gambling, and sex. This turn to the self has destroyed the most fundamental institution for order and flourishing in society: marriage. The toll is incalculable. The wreckage of out-of-wedlock births, broken marriages, divided homes, and the impact on the children at the center of it all cannot easily be described. This is not to mention the human casualty of abortion. Those children, I grimly write, are the sacrifice made to the god of the autotalitarian self.
Autotalitarianism is not only a tyranny to the individual, but becomes totalized through cultural pressure and law. Individuals are subject to this autotalitarianism when socially compelled to comply with each other’s declared sexual or gender identity. Failure to affirm another’s identity is viewed as a bigoted denial of their dignity. In some instances, these denials are considered a form of violence. As such, the denial of another’s self-concept cannot be left as mere differences of opinion to be respected on both sides. Instead, they must be construed as acts of illegal discrimination. Compliance to the dictates of the autonomous self, then, are matters to be enforced by law.[4]
Nevertheless, autotalitarianism is first a tyranny within the individual before it is enforced through culture and law. And theologically speaking, it is first and foremost a reign of sin in the individual. Scripture speaks of sin in this way as slavery, the most comprehensive and brutal sort of tyranny, from which we are set free through faith in Christ. The Apostle Paul writes,
Let not sin therefore reign in your mortal body, to make you obey its passions. Do not present your members to sin as instruments for unrighteousness, but present yourselves to God as those who have been brought from death to life, and your members to God as instruments for righteousness. For sin will not have dominion over you, since you are not under law but under grace (Rom 6:12–14).
Whereas Paul calls the believer to pursue righteousness by the Spirit according to his newfound freedom in Christ, the autonomous self lets sin reign in his body, making him subject to “obey its passions.” The autotalitarian lives under the dominion of sin, rather than the dominion of Christ. And this dominion is cruel, because it directs man away from his Creator and causes him to look inward into his own sinful and deceiving heart for answers to life’s deepest questions. But as the prophet Jeremiah writes, “The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it?” (Jer 17:9). To look into one’s own heart for answers is to stare into the abyss.
Ultimately, autotalitarianism’s end is death (Rom 6:23). It is a destructive reign built on a deceptive but enticing lie — that you can be god and that your will is authoritative.[5] But, as Genesis 3 reminds us, such a temptation is always a lie, and a fatal one. Earthly blessedness and eternal salvation cannot be found by looking within — but without.
A revealed anthropology
That is why at CBMW we look to God and his authoritative self-revelation. We recognize that we are not our own, but belong to him. He created us, forming us with careful design and wise purposes. Rejecting the idea that our will is ultimate, we rely on the will of God as expressed in Scripture and nature. So while the world seeks a true north from within, we declare God’s Word as the only infallible and unchanging rule of faith. And as we look out on our culture’s rejection of God and his Word, we are not surprised to see chaos and destruction. We do not expect to find flourishing people among those who forsake God and his plans and live only according to their own.
One of the great ironies of the autonomous self is that it turns out not to be so autonomous, but highly malleable and subject to manipulation. Claiming to be autonomous, modern man has become enslaved, exchanging the truth of his nature for ideological denials of it. The sudden rise and decline of LGBT-identification in recent years demonstrates just how the turn inward leaves one open to the seduction of online influencers. These viral social trends did not “free” anyone, it chained them to the algorithm.[6] Tragically, in the pursuit of discovering their authentic self, millions of people bought at full price a host of Satanic delusions, invented out of whole cloth by philosophical charlatans hell bent on rebelling against God.
At Eikon, we seek a biblical anthropology, not the anthropology of the university sophists who are always learning but never to arrive at a knowledge of the truth. Nor do we seek the anthropology of the latest social media contagion, of the entertainment industry, or the credentialed bureaucrat. Instead, we seek the only anthropological truth — truth that is anchored in the inerrant and inspired Word of God, in whose image we are made.
[1] John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, ed. John T. McNeill, trans. Ford Lewis
Battles, 1559 translation ed. (Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press, 1960), 43 [1.3.1].
[2] Calvin, Institutes, 44 [1.3.1].
[3] That is, actual marriage as opposed to so-called “same-sex marriage.”
[4] Many such laws are on the book in various states, colloquially called SOGI laws (“sexual orientation and gender identity”).
[5] This is a basic antithesis between Christianity and its alternatives, as Cornelius Van Til recognized: “Over against this Christian view of the will of God as ultimate is the non-Christian view of the will of man as ultimate. Morality is assumed to be autonomous. Man is virtually said to be a law unto himself.” Cornelius Van Til, Christian Apologetics, 2nd Ed. (Phillipburg, NJ: P&R, 2003), 36.
[6] This is a play on the title to a song by Katy Perry, “Chained to the Rhythm.”
Share This Article




