11.20.2026. — Articles

Matthew Vines Says He’s Gay, Not Queer. He Thinks This Matters. Should We?

by Rosaria Butterfield

On June 30, 2026, Matthew Vines, author of God and the Gay Christian and founder of the gay-advocacy program, The Reformation Project, authored a New York Times editorial entitled “I’m Gay, not Queer. It Matters.”[1] Throughout the essay, Matthew Vines makes a categorical and moral distinction between gay (which he defines as a fixed and morally neutral sexual orientation) and queer (a rebellion against the idea of moral norms). Because homosexuality, from desire to action, is rebellion against God’s law and a flourishing society, God does not approve of the moral distinction that Matthew Vines finds so significant.

Matthew opens his piece with this thesis: “Conservative Christian activists are seeking to undo the reason I was able to marry my husband four years ago in a Baptist church in Texas.” The villain in Matthew’s fictional account is a “conservative Christian activist” who rains on his (Pride) parade and disavows his sham marriage.  But what are conservative Christians really doing? They are seeking to conserve the truth of Scripture and to pass that down through the generations, thus fulfilling the command issued in Jude to “contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints” (v. 3). Jude’s sharp charge conveys a dire warning: wolves and false teachers, unregenerate charlatans, “have crept in … ungodly men, who turn the grace of our God into lewdness” (v. 4). Lewdness means indecent sexual conduct or expression, and a biblical example of lewdness is homosexuality. Biblically speaking, conservative Christians know Scripture and know a wolf when he is writing a New York Times editorial. Christians reject so-called “gay marriages” and other attempts to twist God’s law not because we “undo the reason [Matthew] was able to marry his [pretend] husband” but because we love our neighbors with the truth. Christians want all sinners to come to Christ, and so far as it depends on us we will not put a stumbling block between a human being made in God’s image and the God who made him. God creates, redeems, saves, and judges.

No Daylight between “Gay” and “Queer” According to the Bible

Matthew continues his argument by claiming that “Being gay is not a choice.” Accordingly, he rejects the logic of “those who argue that same-sex orientation is better thought of as a part of a wider rebellion against social norms.” On this point Matthew makes two distinct claims. The first is that homosexuality is unchosen and therefore sinless. The second is that even though the Bible calls homosexuality a sin, Matthew calls it “same-sex orientation,” which he believes is a morally neutral set of feelings and desires that are permanent and fixed. What’s the difference between sin and sexual orientation? Bluntly, it’s the difference between a biblical anthropology and a modern man-made one. To demonstrate this, let’s compare Matthew Vines to the Bible.

When sin entered the world, and the hearts of all men fell in Adam, Jesus Christ offered rescue. By faith, Christians receive Christ’s rescue. Christians repent and believe, forsake their sin, and grow in Christ, experiencing what Thomas Chalmers calls “the expulsive power of a new affection.” In Christ, a regenerated man or woman becomes a new creation: “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; the old have passed away, behold, all things have become new” (2 Cor 5:17). When a Christian sins, he doesn’t defend his right to his sin based on the strength of his lust or his good intentions for that lust. He learns to hate his sins, repent of and forsake them, and live in the integrity of his new birth in Christ. A born-again Christian is forgiven through Christ’s blood and liberated from the bondage of sinful habits, deeds, and desires through his resurrection. Sin must be mortified, and we do that through the power that Christ gives us through his death and resurrection. All Christians are enlisted in a war against sin, including the internal, unbidden indwelling sin that we inherit from Adam. Until we are glorified, we are enlisted in a war between the flesh and the indwelling Holy Spirit: “For the flesh lusts against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh; and these are contrary to one another, so that you do not do the things that you wish” (Gal 5:17). Sin may tempt and trick us, but Christians call sin a sin, and reject false teachers and Bible twisters, who, like Matthew, call sin a morally neutral orientation.

The Bible tells us that a regenerated, born-again Christian has the power of the Holy Spirit to mortify his sin, including the sin of homosexuality. Instead of blaming God for his sin nature, he takes Christian ownership over his sin, and, through the process of repentance and belief, kills it. When sin lingers, he says, like Paul, “For what I am doing, I do not understand. For what I will to do, that I do not practice; but what I hate, that I do” (Rom 7:15). The true follower of Christ remembers that the fight against sin is part of our sanctification and because the tomb is empty and we love our Lord, we “present our bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable to God, which is [our] reasonable service” (Rom 12:1).

God’s word, then, tells Matthew Vines that fighting against his unholy sexual desires — including the indwelling sin that no one chooses — is his reasonable service. But because Vines is a Bible-twister, he writes: “Being gay is neither chosen nor changeable, and gay people deserve the same legal protections and chance at happiness as everyone else.” But God says unrepentant sin (including homosexuality) sends you to hell: “Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor sodomites…will inherit the kingdom of God. And such were some of you” (1 Cor 6:9-11). At this point we should not be surprised: God’s word says the exact opposite of Matthew Vines’.

Six Pesky Verses

Matthew declares he “came out”  in 2010 after a “painstaking study of Scripture.” One immediately wonders what kind of “painstaking study” he underwent? He explains:  “All six of the Bible’s references to same-sex relations are negative…but differ fundamentally from same-sex marriages today.” On what planet does working through six verses merit the descriptive adjective “painstaking”?

Matthew says there are six pesky verses — albeit condemning, but don’t dwell on the obvious — and he claims these six and only these six verses deny God’s blessing over the unnatural lust of homosexuality. But the Bible contains 31,086 verses, and every single one is pure and worthy of our study. The Bible is a unified biblical revelation. You cannot remove six verses (or one) to concoct a theological conclusion. The Westminster Confession of Faith has taught a biblical hermeneutic to Christians for hundreds of years. It tells us that the meaning of Scripture “is not manifold, but one,” meaning that the Bible speaks with consistency and clarity, and its meaning does not contradict itself or change over time (WCF 1:9). Jesus is the Logos, the Word made flesh, after all. Furthermore, the Word of God holds authority over all Scripture,  “for which it ought to be believed and obeyed” (WCF 1:4). Using personal lust to dismiss as irrelevant six Bible verses reflects many things, but a  “painstaking study of Scripture” is not one of them.

Martian Desert “Marriages”

Matthew also says “Same-sex love” [is]… as profound and enduring as heterosexual love” [and]… in keeping with a core biblical idea about marriage: that it is a covenant designed to reflect God’s self-giving love for humanity through a sacrificial love of spouses for each other.” But according to the Bible, a core Biblical idea about marriage depends on one man and one woman, reflecting the covenant of Christ and his Bride, the Church. Biblical marriage reflects Christ the husband to his bride, the church. Biblical marriage is a sanctified union that gives life and preserves society. Biblical sexuality is fruitful. Homosexual sex is as barren as a Martian desert. The only fruit it bears is sexually transmitted diseases and destruction through a blatant misuse of the body. God made male and female in a distinct pattern for a creational purpose: men are to lead, provide, and protect, while women are to respect and submit to godly leadership, keep the home, and nurture. Yes, I know them’s fighting words, but I’ll stick with that since it’s plainly revealed in Genesis 1–2 and the rest of Scripture.

Furthermore, heterosexual desire and homosexual desire do not achieve moral equivalency because personal feelings do not stand in judgment over God’s Word. Because unrepented homosexual desire takes you no place but hell, it must be mortified. And in its place, new affections that comport with God’s Word must be prayed for, sparked, quickened, vivified, and established. Heterosexual desire must also be under the authority of biblical boundaries: sexual purity is achieved in biblical marriage or chaste singleness. But only heterosexual desire reflects the pattern and purpose God established when he made us male and female in his image. Can someone sin heterosexually? Yes, but here’s the difference: heterosexual sin is a sin against purpose (i.e., fornication, adultery, pornography), while homosexual sin is a sin against pattern (male and female in the covenant of marriage) and purpose.

Rejecting the Logic of the Gay-Queer Distinction

Matthew says it matters that he’s gay, not queer. By this he means that his homosexuality is normal and blessed by God, but his neighbor’s queer identity is rebellious and condemned. Christians reject his deceptive argument. Like all unregenerate thinkers, Matthew is both deceived and deceiver. If you believe him, you need to accept the lie that says there is such a thing as a gay man. There is no such ontological thing as a gay man. Homosexuality is not part of the created order. Like it or not, Matthew is a man, made in the Image of God, for the purpose of sexual purity, chastity in singleness or fruitfulness in godly marriage, filling the earth and stewarding it (Gen 1:26–28). The particular kind of man that Matthew represents is not a gay one, but a coward, someone who shirks his duties to repent and believe and dodges his responsibility to protect and provide for a woman in a real marriage.

So while Matthew Vines says he’s gay but not queer, Christians cannot accept his logic. The fact that Matthew doesn’t march his “boyfriend” on all fours down the streets of Manhattan at the Gay Pride festival on a tactical leather agitation collar and doesn’t take estrogen and wear girls’ panties does not make his sin against God any less hell-bound than those who do. When Matthew Vines says he’s gay, not queer, it means that he knows what a man is. But because he rejects what a man is for, this means he’s still as queer as a three-eyed fish.

[1] Matthew Vines, “I’m Gay, Not Queer. It Matters,” New York Times, June 30, 2026, https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/30/opinion/queer-gay-right,s.html.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Share This Article

  • Dead trees in a desert landscape with sand dunes

    Autotalitarianism: the Tyranny of the Self | Editorial

    By Jonathan Swan

  • a desert with a mountain in the background

    Matthew Vines Says He’s Gay, Not Queer. He Thinks This Matters. Should We?

    By Rosaria Butterfield

  • The Seceda mountains in Ortisei, Italy, with a green ridge and yellow wildflowers

    Married Love: Lessons from Spurgeon’s Love Poem | Ancient Paths

    By Geoff Chang

View All Articles
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
Click Here Click Here
Malcare WordPress Security