The future of complementarianism depends, in part, on which complementarianism we mean. That term once named a recognizable and broadly consistent position held by Christians who affirmed the Bible’s teachings on the sexes. It has since become apparent that complementarians come in two kinds. Like Judah and Israel, these camps share a common origin but have divergent trajectories. The essential points of division concern the scope of male and female differences, the reason the differences exist, and the extent to which these differences should shape all of life.
Recall that at its founding in the late 1980s (when the Danvers Statement was drafted), complementarianism affirmed the long-held conviction that men and women are “equal before God as persons and distinct in their manhood and womanhood (Gen. 1:26–27, 2:18).”[1] It is true that Danvers does not spell out every place where biblical authors assign significance to sexual differences, nor every sphere where these differences are expressed. It is, intentionally, a very brief statement that was never meant to say all that could be said about men and women but was only meant to affirm the foundation. After all, its framers expounded voluminously on their views, showing that most of the statement’s earliest adherents seemed to understand that the import of sexual difference extends beyond a handful of biblical texts.[2]
To the point, Denny Burk has recently argued that the statement’s omissions were an intentional move to avoid “controversial matters that [the drafters] knew might otherwise divide complementarians.”[3] Such strategies have long been part of prudential plans for building solid coalitions, but after forty years it increasingly looks as though this gambit has not worked. Instead, the movement seems to be splintering into what has come to be known as “broad” and “narrow” (a.k.a. “thick” and “thin” or “hard” and “soft”) complementarianism.[4] And I am far from alone in my doubts as to whether these two camps can continue to share a common label for much longer.
It is likely that the roots of the current division were present from the beginning, though I think they were largely unseen and temporarily underrealized. To be sure, not all complementarians had an equally developed theology of the sexes. Yet virtually all complementarians thirty-plus years ago were still culturally conservative in ways that reinforced — even when imperfectly understood or insufficiently applied — the basic thrust of their theology. As a result, their families, churches, and general interactions typically placed a high significance on male and female differences.
That is no longer the case. The unity in the complementarian movement, to whatever extent it formerly existed, has weakened considerably in the last decade or so. Indeed, more and more of those who continue to embrace the label of “complementarianism” now deny many of its implicit premises as well as its explicit applications. Hence it is now common to hear of self-avowed complementarians arguing that “anything that an unordained man is allowed to do, a woman is also allowed to do,”[5] that women can preach in the Sunday gathering,[6] and that women may even serve as pastors.[7]
Those authors all affirm the Danvers Statement while espousing positions with only a hair’s breadth between their views and that of egalitarians. But some have gone even further. A recent book by a professor at a prominent Southern Baptist seminary addressed the complementarity of the sexes in such a way that egalitarians heralded the book as a triumph for their position. As CBE author Hashim Warren says of that book, “Allison’s complementarity… is mutuality [i.e., egalitarianism].”[8] Warren goes on to say that egalitarianism is “precisely what Allison’s theological framework supports, even as he hesitates to embrace the label.”[9]
Here, then, is the future of complementarianism. On one side will be those who see the sexual differences in God’s design as prior to and instructive for all the “rules” and “roles” that God assigns to men and women. As a result, these adherents are keen to explore the significance of male-female differences in all arenas of life in view of both the principles set forth in Scripture and the facts of God’s other book, creation.[10]
On the other side are those who limit what they say about women and men to the barest handful of biblical texts (e.g., 1 Cor 11:2–16, Eph 5:21–33, and 1 Tim 2:8–15), which many avoid as often as they can. Yet when they do speak about these texts, they fail to ground God’s directives in God’s design. That is to say, they fail to give sufficient account for the why (God’s created order) behind the what (God’s commands). In so doing, they make God’s commands appear to be utterly arbitrary. And arbitrary orders — as every parent knows — won’t hold the obedience of any child for long.
Besides all this, we now live in a culture where any differences between men and women are seen as obstacles to True Equality™ that must therefore be eradicated or destroyed. This growing gap between the world’s view of men and women and the Bible’s teaching on the same will continue to place tremendous pressure on Christians to conform or be “cancelled.” And those complementarians who routinely diminish the significance of sexual differences will be the first to cave. Many already have.
I’m neither a prophet nor the son of a prophet, but I suspect it won’t be long before many of complementarianism’s strongest adherents begin to jettison that term. Why should they want to share a label with those who are ashamed of the church’s centuries-long consensus concerning God’s design of the sexes? As for the other complementarian camp, I urge them to recognize that adopting a maximally thin framework will not alleviate the mounting pressure to conform to the world. For you cannot appease those who are departing from God’s design by reducing it to the barest of threads; all you can do is water down “the faith once for all delivered to the saints” (Jude 3).
[1] The Danvers Statement, Affirmation 1, The Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, November 1988, https://cbmw.org/about/danvers-statement/.
[2] See, for example, John Piper and Wayne Grudem, Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood: A Response to Evangelical Feminism, 3rd. edition (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2021).
[3] Denny Burk, Mere Complementarianism: Male and Female in the Image of God (Geanies House, Fearn, Ross-shire: Christian Focus, 2026), 21.
[4] For an extensive overview of these distinctions, see Andy Naselli, “Does Anyone Need to Recover from Biblical Manhood and Womanhood?” Eikon 2.1 (Spring 2020): 109–151.
[5] Kathy Keller, Jesus, Justice, & Gender Roles: A Case for Gender Roles in Ministry (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2012), 21 (emphasis added).
[6] See, for example, Andrew Wilson, “Women Preachers: A Response to John Piper,” Think (blog), May 6, 2015. See also John Dickson, Hearing Her Voice: A Biblical Invitation for Women to Preach (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Academic, 2013).
[7] See Sam Storms, “A Complementarian Case for Women Pastors – Part One,” Enjoying God (blog), May 28, 2026.
[8] Hashim Warren, “Book Review: Complementarity: Dignity, Difference, and Interdependence,” CBE International (blog), February 18, 2026.
[9] Ibid.
[10] See John Calvin, The Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book 1.5–6.
Share This Article




