11.17.2026. — Articles

Returning to the Vision of Danvers

by Denny Burk

The grimmest prediction about the future of complementarianism came about seven years ago from Aaron Renn, who wrote that “Complementarianism Is a Baby Boomer Theology That Will Die with the Baby Boomers.” He explained,

The future of complementarianism looks grim, because it was developed as a response to a specific set of cultural circumstances in the late 1980s that no longer exist, and because it’s a theology of the Baby Boomers, especially the early half of that generation, that seems likely to fade away along with them.[1]

I disagreed with this assessment at the time and said so in writing and in a conversation with Renn on his podcast.[2] This prediction reduces complementarianism to a social trend within evangelicalism and overlooks the fact that complementarianism is fundamentally a theological proposition. As such, it either faithfully reflects what the Bible teaches or it doesn’t. If it does, then it can no more go extinct than the Bible and the people of God can go extinct (Isa 40:8; Matt 16:18). In that sense, you can rest assured that complementarianism as a biblical doctrine isn’t going anywhere.

But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t significant challenges facing the people of God as they stand upon what the Bible teaches concerning manhood and womanhood. Those challenges come both from without and from within.

Post-modern feminism, queer theory, and the secular spirit of the age all conspire from without to undermine the teaching and exert pressure upon God’s people to abandon the Bible’s vision for marriage and the sexes. From within, there are varying responses to this pressure — some wishing to capitulate as much as possible to the spirit of the age while softening the harder edges of biblical doctrine and others doubling down on biblical doctrine while advancing a legally binding patriarchy within a Christian Nationalist conquest of the political order.

Both of these alternatives are extremely problematic and in some ways undermine what the Bible and nature reveal about God’s will for the sexes.

Is the future soft-complementarian?

So-called “soft complementarianism” in its worst forms is little more than soft egalitarianism.[3] They want to apply complementarian doctrine narrowly to two spheres — the church and the home. A husband should be a faithful head of his wife, and the office of pastor is limited to men who meet the Bible’s qualifications for church leadership. Outside of those two narrow prohibitions, men’s and women’s roles are basically interchangeable. In the home, that means that husbands may on rare occasions have to cast a tie-breaking vote when there is disagreement with his wife, but other than that the marriage is functionally egalitarian. A husband’s “servant leadership” ends up being long on serving and short on authority and leadership.

In the church, qualified men are called to hold the office of leadership, but otherwise there is very little if any gender-based guidance for a church’s ministry. For example, in her little book Jesus, Justice, & Gender Roles, Kathy Keller argues that women ought to be allowed to serve in any role in the church that an unordained man is allowed to serve in. Care must be taken not to transgress the biblical prohibition on women serving as elders. Otherwise, women may serve in any avenue of ministry that an unordained man can.[4]

But this vision of things is a far cry from the norms described in the Danvers Statement — which is the defining doctrinal articulation of complementarianism. Danvers reflects the biblical teaching that some governing and teaching roles are exclusively for qualified men. It also affirms that husbands are heads of their homes and that wives should submit to that leadership. Soft complementarianism chaffs against these norms and tries to bend the teaching to accommodate egalitarian sensibilities. That is not the original Danvers vision, and it’s not going to be the future of complementarianism. It’s more likely to be a weigh-station to egalitarianism than anything else.

Is the future patriarchy?

On the other end of the spectrum, some have argued that a new Christian patriarchy is the only way to stand against the headwinds of egalitarianism and feminism. They argue that soft complementarianism is complementarianism, is therefore doctrinally compromised, and cannot provide a bulwark against an encroaching feminism. A much harder line must be drawn. Men must rule over women not only in the church and the home but also in the wider society. Patriarchy is the state of nature. It is the way things are in spite of ideologies. The only question is what kind of patriarchy we will have — one defined by biblical standards or one defined by godless ones.

To the degree that biblical patriarchy overlaps with biblical teaching (and there is much that does), that is all to the good. However, the biblical patriarchy movement is not without its problems, some of them very serious.

For starters, the use of the term “patriarchy” is misleading.[5] A word’s meaning is established by usage, and the term patriarchy is the coinage of second wave feminists (see Kate Millet) who defined patriarchy as a virtual synonym for misogyny and abuse. Consequently, the term doesn’t communicate “benevolent father-rule” to most people but something perniciously tied to the misuse and abuse of women. As a prudential matter, this is an unwise way to self-identify. Nevertheless, many advocates of biblical patriarchy view the misunderstanding as a feature and not a bug. After all, it’s a chance to “own the libs” by provoking their ire.

And that points to another downside of the biblical patriarchy movement. It functions as more of a vibe than an explicit doctrinal proposition. The term patriarchy has no creedal definition. Phrases like biblical patriarchy or Christian patriarchy lack confessional standing and refer loosely to a movement that emphasizes male authority in every sphere of life. Because of this lack of definition, a number of fringe teachings and practices have flown under the banner of “biblical patriarchy.” Here I’m thinking about wife-spanking (corporal punishment for disobedient wives), false teachings about “umbrellas of authority,” the repeal of the 19th amendment (which granted women the right to vote), and more. Moreover, biblical patriarchy tends to be associated with a Christian Nationalist vision of the political order, and in some cases with explicitly fascist interpretations of the faith.[6]

I am not accusing everyone who adopts the label “biblical patriarchy” of such aberrant practices and beliefs. I know that there are many who believe almost identically to what I believe. Nevertheless, it is a problem for proponents of biblical patriarchy that there is no doctrinal standard or confession by which to adjudicate errors in their movement. They have no formal way of saying “biblical patriarchy is this and not that.”

Advocates of biblical patriarchy promote a “consistent biblical view of men and women where men rule in the home, church, and society.”[7] While I would agree that male and female difference has implications wherever men and women can be found, that does not mean that all men have God-given authority to rule all women. And this is one key area in which advocates of biblical patriarchy need some confessional clarity (which they currently lack). Scripture teaches that a husband is the head of his own wife, not the head of anyone else’s wife (1 Cor. 11:3; Eph. 5:23). Likewise, the Bible teaches that a wife should submit to her own husband, not to all men (Eph. 5:23-24). While creation design has implications for all of life, it does not imply a necessary relation of authority and submission in every sphere of life.

While it may go against the grain of nature for women to “rule” in certain roles, that does not mean that all men have authority over all women in every sphere of life. It is these kinds of distinctions and definitions that are sometimes missing from the biblical patriarchy movement. The result is that much of the movement relies heavily on masculine vibes rather than on confessional clarity about how creation order cashes-out in the various spheres of life. Confessional clarity would offer an articulation of principles that can be true no matter the vicissitudes of life in this fallen world.

The way forward is complementarian

I still believe that the way forward for complementarianism is the vision that was laid out in Danvers. We do not need to split the difference between soft complementarianism and patriarchy and call that truth. Rather, we need to attend to nature and to Scripture — all of God’s revelation — and reconcile our doctrine and our lives to that revelation. There are God-ordained differences between male and female that are rooted in God’s design of creation. Those differences relate not only to reproductive roles but also to social roles like headship and helpership. Those social differences have implications not only for the church and the home but for wherever men and women may be found. For men and women don’t cease to be men and women when they go outside home and church. That is the original vision of Danvers, and it should be the ongoing vision of complementarianism.

[1] Aaron Renn, “Complementarianism Is a Baby Boomer Theology That Will Die with the Baby Boomers,” The Masculinist (New York, NY, February 14, 2019), http://www.aaronrenn.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/The-Masculinist-30-Complementarianism-Is-a-Baby-Boomer-Theology.pdf. See also Jake Meador, “Will Complementarianism Die with the Baby Boomers?,” Mere Orthodoxy, March 5, 2019, https://mereorthodoxy.com/complementarianism/. Aaron Renn and I had a productive discussion about all this two years later on his podcast. See Complementarianism and Its Discontents (with Denny Burk), The Aaron Renn Show, May 5, 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KvG2l_4wOuM.

[2] Complementarianism and Its Discontents (with Denny Burk), The Aaron Renn Show, May 5, 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KvG2l_4wOu

[3] What follows is adapted from my book Mere Complementarianism: Male and Female in the Image of God (Christian Focus, 2026), 4-6.

[4] Kathy Keller, Jesus, Justice, & Gender Roles: A Case for Gender Roles in Ministry, Fresh Perspectives on Women in Ministry (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2012), 29, 34.

[5] What follows is an adaptation of appendix 4 in my book Mere Complementarianism.

[6] “New Christendom Press Under Fire After Conference Vendor Promoted, Hawked Nazi Books and ‘Pro-White’ Groups,” Protestia (June 15, 2026), https://protestia.com/2026/06/15/new-christendom-press-under-fire-after-conference-vendor-promoted-hawked-nazi-books-and-pro-white-groups/.

[7] Zachary M. Garris, Masculine Christianity (Reformation Zion, 2021), ix. Garris writes, “The same nature that prohibits a woman from exercising familial authority prohibits her from exercising civil authority,” (Garris, Masculine Christianity, 244).

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
  • Denny Burk is the President of the Council on Biblical Manhood & Womanhood. He joined the faculty of Boyce College in 2008, where he currently serves as Professor of Biblical Studies. He also serves as one of the preaching pastors at Kenwood Baptist Church in Louisville, Kentucky. He has written extensively about the Bible's teaching on sexuality and gender, including Male and Female He Created Them (Christian Focus, 2023), Transforming Homosexuality (P&R, 2015), and What Is the Meaning of Sex? (Crossway, 2013). He has also authored a commentary on the pastoral epistles (Crossway, 2017) and has written articles that have appeared in the Journal for the Study of the New Testament, Tyndale Bulletin, Bulletin for Biblical Research, and the Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society. He is married and has four children.

    View all posts

Share This Article

  • green leaf tree under sun set

    The Inevitability of Patriarchy

    By Joe Rigney

  • aerial photography of river between mountains

    A Tale of Two Complementarianisms

    By Doug Ponder

  • a forest filled with lots of tall green trees

    Returning to the Vision of Danvers

    By Denny Burk

View All Articles
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
Click Here Click Here
Malcare WordPress Security