11.17.2026. — Articles

Gender in Deep Heaven

by Kyle Dillon

In the second novel of C.S. Lewis’s Ransom Trilogy, the main character Dr. Elwin Ransom travels to planet Venus, known as Perelandra in the Old Solar language.[1] His mission is to prevent the unfallen natives from disobeying the command of the divine ruler Maleldil and from plunging the planet into sin and ruin. The novel thus serves as an imaginative exploration of the question, what might the world have been like if the Fall had been averted? Paradise — not lost, nor regained — but kept?

After succeeding in his task — though at great injury to himself — Ransom journeys on foot into a mountain pass, where he encounters the two Oyarsas (presiding angels) of Malacandra (Mars) and Perelandra. To prepare for the arrival of the newly glorified King Tor and Queen Tinidril (the Perelandrian equivalent of Adam and Eve), the Oyarsas assume visible form as two tall, radiant human figures. Lewis describes them in these words:

The two white creatures were sexless. But he of Malacandra was masculine (not male); she of Perelandra was feminine (not female). Malacandra seemed to him to have the look of one standing armed, at the ramparts of his own remote archaic world, in ceaseless vigilance, his eyes ever roaming the earth-ward horizon whence his danger came long ago. . . . But the eyes of Perelandra opened, as it were, inward, as if they were the curtained gateway to a world of waves and murmurings and wandering airs, of life that rocked in winds and splashed on mossy stones and descended as the dew and arose sunward in thin-spun delicacy of mist.[2]

Ransom thus discovered that gender is a deeper reality than sex. Sex is “merely the adaptation to organic life of a fundamental polarity which divides all created beings.”[3] Maleness and femaleness are the concrete symbols; masculinity and femininity are the realities signified. In Lewis’s fictional telling, even the landscapes of Mars and Venus reflect this cosmic gender binary: the former is cold, austere, and angular, while the latter is warm, fertile, and undulating. In brief, sex is biological, but gender is metaphysical.

Or so Lewis would have us accept. But is this idea biblical? Are masculinity and femininity truly rooted in Scripture, or are they merely social constructs? Many contemporary Christians take a minimalist approach on the question. For example, Rachel Green Miller, a critic of complementarian theology, writes, “If God made you a woman, you are feminine. . . . If God made you a man, you are masculine.”[4] On this view, gender is virtually reducible to biological sex. Anything beyond this, it is claimed, is stereotyping.

Gender in the Creation Order

There are, however, good biblical reasons for taking a broader view of gender. Following the logic of Jesus and the Apostle Paul (Matt 19:3–9; 1 Cor 11:7–16; 1 Tim 2:12–15), we can look to the creation order itself in Genesis 1–3. There we read that Adam was formed first, then Eve. Adam was formed from and for the earth, Eve from and for Adam. Adam was a guardian and laborer, Eve a helper and companion. Mankind is named after Adam, but Eve is named by Adam. Adam was called out for his sin first, even though Eve was first to disobey. Adam was cursed in his work, Eve in her family relationships. These features of the story are more than incidental.

If we accept Adam and Eve to be paradigms for masculinity and femininity, then certain conclusions follow. Given our creational design, we would expect men to be initiators, more aggressive, and more task-oriented. We would expect women to be responders, more nurturing, and more relationship-oriented. We would also expect men and women to be prone to different vices; this explains why Paul warns men against anger and quarreling (1 Tim 2:8) and women against immodesty, gossip, and meddling (1 Tim 2:9; 5:13).

It is, of course, important to avoid certain misunderstandings: gender norms are not grounded merely in general behavioral patterns or statistical bell curves. After all, there will always be certain outliers of both genders — some men will be more nurturing, and some women will be more aggressive. Rather, the point is that Adam and Eve each express a fundamentally different telos or orientation to life, which in turn gives rise to both the gender norms and the general behavioral patterns.

Likewise, we would be mistaken to treat these norms as an absolute and inflexible standard in all circumstances. While men will ordinarily gravitate toward masculine behaviors and women toward feminine behaviors, there are appropriate exceptions. Consider the Apostle Paul, who told the Thessalonians that he had been “gentle” and “affectionate” toward them like a mother (1 Thess 2:7–8), but he also “exhorted” and “encouraged” them like a father (1 Thess 2:11–12). Paul recognizes that mothers are generally more affectionate and fathers are more directive. Now sometimes a man may act maternally or a woman paternally, but the real differences between them nevertheless remain.

So far, I’m not saying anything that many others haven’t already said before. But I want to press the argument further and show how masculinity has an even more basic foundation in God himself. I want to make the case that Lewis was right after all: gender is not merely biological, but metaphysical and cosmological. It’s grounded in God’s very relationship to creation. As Ransom later expressed it, “What is above and beyond all things is so masculine that we are all feminine in relation to it.”[5]

Divine Masculinity in Scripture and History

Now this is an area where contemporary evangelicals differ among themselves. Some have argued that a wife’s submission to her husband is grounded in the Son’s eternal submission to the Father. Critics, however, have noted that this sort of argument is unprecedented in earlier church history and undermines the classical doctrine of divine simplicity, whereby God possesses one undivided will, without any distinctions of authority in the Trinitarian relations. On this point, I side with the critics.[6]

And yet the Trinitarian relations do reveal something relevant to gender. After all, God has revealed himself to us with the names “Father” and “Son,” not “Mother” and “Daughter.” And even though the word for “spirit” is grammatically feminine in Hebrew (ruaḥ) and neuter in Greek (pneuma), the Holy Spirit is sometimes described in masculine terms in both testaments (e.g., Isa 40:13; John 16:13). Is this terminology simply an accommodation to the patriarchal culture in which the Bible was written, or does it communicate something more meaningful about God’s being?

While firmly denying that God is “male” in any corporeal sense, Christians have historically insisted on using masculine language for God. By contrast, plenty of ancient pagan religions spoke of God in feminine terms — the Canaanites had Asherah, the Egyptians had Isis, and the Babylonians had Tiamat. The later Gnostics also spoke of a feminine divinity, variously referred to as Achamoth, Sophia, or even the Holy Spirit. This belies the claim that biblical language had to accommodate patriarchal culture; goddess worship was widespread at that time. And yet, despite the pressures toward pagan syncretism, Bible-believing Christians remained united in their confession of God as Father, not Mother.

This historic consensus has come under attack with the rise of feminist theology since the 1960s. The critics are not monolithic, and some have moved further away from Christian orthodoxy than others. Mary Daly, one of the first feminist theologians, eventually renounced Christianity.[7] Others like Sally McFague and Elizabeth Johnson continued to identify as Christian, but in a fundamentally resymbolized form.[8] Additionally, numerous mainline denominations and organizations have sought to revise their confessions and liturgies in line with more gender-inclusive language for God. Rather than referring to Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, they speak of Creator, Redeemer, and Sanctifier. More radical theologians like Rosemary Ruether and Carol Christ have even adopted explicitly feminine titles for God, like “Womb of Being” and “Primal Matrix.”[9]

Centrist and Egalitarian Responses to Feminist Revisionism

It may come as a surprise that the most thorough responses to feminist revisions of Scripture’s God-language have come not from conservative evangelical complementarians or patriarchalists, but from centrist and egalitarian mainline theologians such as Elizabeth Achtemeier (PCUSA), Donald Bloesch (UCC), and Alvin Kimel (formerly Episcopal).[10] One of the best responses is by John W. Cooper (CRCNA), retired professor of philosophical theology at Calvin Theological Seminary.[11] Cooper provides an exhaustive treatment of both feminine and masculine references to God in Scripture, concluding that the differences between them are both quantitative and qualitative. On the one hand, there are about two dozen feminine references to God in Scripture, all of which are figurative in form, such as similes and metaphors (Isa 66:13; Matt 23:37). On the other hand, there are thousands of masculine references to God in the form of titles and appellatives, as well as grammatically masculine parts of speech such as verb forms, pronouns, and adjectives. So although the Bible occasionally uses feminine imagery for God, the names of God are exclusively masculine.

And yet Cooper stops short of concluding that God is masculine. Rather, his claim is merely that “Scripture speaks of God as though he is masculine or as anthropomorphically masculine.”[12] While acknowledging that the biblical text doesn’t strictly deny God’s masculinity, Cooper argues on philosophical grounds that, as a perfect being, God cannot have partial, contingent, or correlative attributes. And since masculinity and femininity are partial, contingent, and correlative attributes, God must transcend gender.[13]

Although there is some truth in this claim, I think calling God’s masculinity merely anthropomorphic is too weak. Anthropomorphism is a type of metaphor — an improper or secondary signification — such as when we attribute to God repentance, jealousy, or grief.[14] Such a characterization would make the Bible’s masculine language for God categorically equivalent to its feminine language, undermining Cooper’s own argument that the differences between them are not only quantitative but also qualitative. I believe it’s truer to Scripture to speak of God’s masculinity as a form of proper or primary signification rather than as a mere literary trope.[15]

Relatedly, Cooper is unable to give a compelling reason why, if God is beyond gender, he has nevertheless chosen to reveal himself in predominantly masculine rather than feminine language. To be sure, Cooper denies that the biblical pattern is arbitrary, and he suggests possible nongendered reasons why the Bible privileges masculine language for God.[16] And yet he also suggests the hypothetical possibility that God could have revealed himself in predominantly feminine language: “Perhaps God could have chosen to reveal himself as Mother or Father-Mother without misrepresentation and still have accomplished his redemptive purposes in the world. But he didn’t.”[17] Following this same logic, one could also say that Christ could hypothetically have chosen to become incarnate as a woman.

Cooper’s stance on divine genderlessness reveals an underlying lack of clarity on what gender actually is. On the one hand, he recognizes that it might extend beyond biological sex.[18] On the other hand, he is reluctant to define gender by stereotypical patterns.[19] But where does that then leave us? How can he say that God’s masculinity is merely anthropomorphic without first specifying what ontological masculinity even means? Without a clearly defined ontology of gender, we are also left with no coherent justification for normative gender differences. It should therefore come as no surprise that Cooper holds an egalitarian view of women’s ordination.[20]

A more recent critic of divine masculinity is Amy Peeler, an Episcopal professor at Wheaton College. She attempts to harmonize Scripture’s gendered language with God’s genderlessness through a creative appeal to the doctrine of the Incarnation:

A patriarchal society and the few glimmers of God’s fatherhood in the Scriptures of Israel do not fully explain the incarnate Son’s linguistic expression of his eternal, personal, and begotten relationship with God. If the eternal relationship was the motivation, Jesus should call God “Father,” or “Mother,” or “Parent” even. It must be the incarnation that narrows the fitting choice for divine address. Jesus does not call God “Mother” because he already has one.[21]

According to Peeler, when God is considered in se (in himself, that is, apart from his redemptive acts), feminine language is just as valid as masculine language. Only the Incarnation constitutes God’s designation as Christ’s Father, being a fitting complement to Mary’s role as Christ’s mother. Peeler then combines this move with a peculiar view of the uniqueness of Christ’s mediatorial role: since Christ is without a biological father, he is the only man derived from female-only flesh, and for this reason he is uniquely able to represent both men and women as their Redeemer.[22] Thus Christ’s maleness would be no hindrance to affirming the genderlessness of God — or the ordination of women.

There are, however,  three problems with Peeler’s argument. First, it does not account for the overwhelmingly masculine language used for God in the Old Testament, which is not grounded in the Incarnation. Second, the New Testament describes God as the Father of Christ even in his preincarnate state (John 8:54–58; 17:5, 24; 1 John 1:1–2). In order for Peeler’s argument to work, she must posit that God’s paternal designation is retroactively applied before the Incarnation. But this is simply special pleading. Nowhere does Scripture teach that the designation of God’s Fatherhood depends upon Mary’s motherhood. Rather, as evangelical Trinitarian scholar Fred Sanders argues:

The first person of the Trinity is God the Father. God is called the Father, in the first place, for Trinitarian reasons. He is the Father because he is the Father of the Son, from eternity, at home in the happy land of the Trinity. He did not become the Father at Christmas, or at any point in human history, or in any pretemporal history. He did not undergo any transformation from being not-the-Father to being the Father.[23]

The third problem is that Peeler’s view gives us no coherent reason why redemptive history could not have unfolded with all of the gender roles reversed. Consider the following hypothetical scenario: God reveals “herself” as heavenly Mother and Daughter rather than as Father and Son. The Mother then appoints a man to be the human father of the female incarnate Christ — perhaps in some miraculous way similar to God forming Eve from Adam’s rib.[24] In this way, Christ could be the only woman derived from male-only flesh, and would therefore be able to represent both women and men as their Redemptrix. Now there are two possibilities here: either egalitarian logic is sound and this scenario is in principle just as valid as the manner of redemption that God actually chose, or else this scenario is fundamentally opposed to the logic of orthodox Christianity. I am convinced of the latter.[25]

Ultimately, those who wish to uphold the authority of Scripture’s masculine God-language while denying God’s masculinity are in the same predicament as “narrow” complementarians, who try to restrict Scripture’s commands on gender roles to marital headship and church eldership, but who cannot give an explanation for why these commands exist in the first place. That is, they leave us rules without reasons.[26] I don’t think this accurately reflects the teaching of Scripture, which presents masculine language for God not as arbitrary but as a more suitable expression of his character. Roman Catholic philosopher Peter Kreeft correctly observes:

The masculinity of God is not part of the shell, but part of the nut. It is not like Hebrew grammar, a translatable and replaceable medium. Something as deliberate and distinctive and as all-pervasive in Scripture as God’s he-ness is no mere accident. . . .[27]

Therefore, I believe we must conclude that God is masculine in some sense that is more than just anthropomorphic. But in exactly what sense?

Mapping Divine Attributes and Gender 

Here I want to build on the recent work of Kyle Claunch on divine fatherhood.[28] Claunch highlights the traditional distinction between God’s absolute attributes and relative attributes. Absolute attributes are those which God would have possessed even if he had chosen not to create the world — such as immutability and immensity. Cooper’s claim that a perfect being would be incapable of possessing contingent or correlative attributes is valid, but this only applies to God’s absolute attributes.

On the other hand, relative attributes are those which God is said to possess by virtue of his free decision to create the world. These include attributes such as justice and mercy (since these presuppose sin), as well as titles such as Creator, Sustainer, and Judge.[29] Now given divine immutability and simplicity, we must deny that God’s relative attributes entail any change or composition in his being. In that sense, the relative attributes are not “real” in God, although they are “real” to us.[30] God does not actually “become” merciful; rather, this is a way of describing God according to his outward acts toward creatures. And yet we would never claim that God is only “anthropomorphically” merciful. For us, it is the truest kind of mercy conceivable, of which human mercy is only a pale shadow.[31]

Claunch has made a persuasive case that fatherhood should also be understood as one of God’s relative attributes, since it applies primarily and eminently to God, and only secondarily and derivatively to human fatherhood.[32] Extending this same principle more broadly, I want to argue that masculinity is a relative attribute of God — a proper way of describing him according to a certain general “habitude” or disposition toward creation.[33]

To defend this claim, it’s necessary to provide a more precise definition of masculinity. Following Lewis, I take gender to be a more fundamental reality than sex. So I view masculinity not simply as a set of social roles or duties arising from biological maleness (in which case God clearly could not be masculine in any literal sense), but as a disposition consisting primarily in a set of certain qualities oriented to the exercise of divine dominion.[34] This definition can be contrasted with femininity as a disposition consisting primarily in a set of certain qualities complementary to masculinity, which are oriented to the support of the exercise of divine dominion.

Now this requires clarification: the contrast between masculinity and femininity is not an absolute opposition but a relative one. A man possesses masculine qualities in a primary sense but may also possess feminine qualities in a secondary sense. Conversely, a woman possesses feminine qualities in a primary sense but may also possess masculine qualities in a secondary sense. I believe that this primary-secondary distinction is necessary for three reasons. First, it upholds the biblical testimony that God possesses the perfections of both masculinity and femininity while remaining properly and primarily masculine. Second, it accounts for instances in Scripture where men express typically feminine traits (e.g., Paul’s maternal affection in 1 Thess 2:7–8) or where women express typically masculine traits (e.g., Ruth taking romantic initiative with Boaz). And third, it allows us to balance the situational flexibility of gendered behaviors with the normative fixity of gender roles.[35]

Roman Catholic philosopher J. Budziszewski captures this dynamic well in describing masculinity as the potential for fatherhood and femininity as the potential for motherhood:

When all goes well, fathers and mothers also exemplify and specialize in different aspects of wisdom. A wise father teaches his wife and family that in order to love you must be strong; a wise mother teaches her husband and family that in order to be strong you must love. She knows that even boldness needs humility; he knows that even humility needs to be bold. He is an animate symbol to his children of that justice which is tempered by mercy, she a living emblem of that mercy which is tempered by justice.[36]

There is also a certain primacy to masculinity over femininity, not only chronologically (1 Tim 2:13) but also teleologically (1 Cor 11:7–9). Donald Bloesch perceptively writes, “Femininity is grounded in masculinity and not vice versa. . . . But as the masculine is the foundation of the feminine, so the feminine is the flower and fruit of the masculine, the glory of the masculine.”[37] This principle explains why the Bible’s gendered language for God is not reversible, and also why covenant representatives in Scripture are exclusively men. Because masculinity is primary, it can represent femininity, but femininity cannot represent masculinity. Thus humanity can be designated collectively as “man” but not as “woman” (Gen 1:26–27).

Having established these foundational elements of our definitions of masculinity and femininity, we can now briefly identify a list of specific contrasting qualities that distinguish them. I treat this list as suggestive rather than exhaustive, and I again emphasize that the opposition of these qualities is relative rather than absolute:

  • Externality vs. internality. This is tied to one of the central distinctions highlighted by defenders of God’s masculinity.[38] In emphasizing divine immanence, feminist theology frequently tends in the direction of panentheism, implying a certain ontological continuity between God and the world to which God “gives birth.” Masculinity, on the other hand, is especially apt to symbolize creation ex nihilo, since creation proceeds not from God’s “womb” but from his word.[39] Masculinity thus signifies externality or transcendent “otherness” in a way that femininity does not. Of course, God is also immanent, but his transcendence is still primary, with immanence best conceived as a divine movement “toward” creation rather than simply a static presence “in” creation.
  • Initiative vs. responsiveness. This principle naturally follows from the chronological priority of masculinity, expressed in the parallel between God’s priority over creation and Adam’s priority over Eve. Adam’s mission came first, and Eve was created to support him in his mission. This distinction is also reflected in God’s initiative in entering into covenants with humanity. It also accounts for the general pattern of men’s goal orientation, in contrast to women’s personal need orientation.[40]
  • Authority vs. submission. This is a fundamental gender distinction, though egalitarians are resistant to acknowledge it.[41] Yet if God is the supreme authority and has intentionally revealed himself in masculine terms, then it follows that men would be more apt representatives of his authority than women. Of course, this does not imply that all men have authority over all women, or that women may never exercise authority over men in any circumstances, but it does explain why those offices that are instituted to communicate divine authority are reserved for men only.[42]
  • Strength vs. tenderness. In this case, there is a much more obvious connection between biology and gender. God has designed men with generally greater muscle mass, higher bone density, and a stronger cardiovascular system — all of which translates into greater physical strength. This makes men a clearer expression of God’s omnipotence. It also accounts for men’s particular orientation to the martial virtues, such as vigilance, perseverance, and courage (see 1 Cor 16:13).
  • Discipline vs. nurture. A central teaching of Scripture is how God disciplines us the way a father disciplines his son (Prov 3:11–12; Heb 12:5–11). Authors Katy Faust and Stacy Manning similarly note how fathers reflect “the world” to their children, while mothers reflect “the home.”[43] Fathers teach their children through failure and consequences, in order to foster a sense of agency and a readiness to engage the adult world. Mothers, on the other hand, tend to respond intuitively to the physical and emotional needs of their children in order to create a safe and secure environment. Of course, God relates to us in both modes, but fatherly discipline is a more fitting description of Christian sanctification.
  • Linear vs. cyclical. God can also be regarded as primarily masculine in his ordering of time.[44] Since men are more task-oriented and mission-focused, they approach time from a more linear perspective, with a definite beginning and end. This corresponds to the biblical progression of salvation history in creation, fall, redemption, and restoration. On the other hand, in ancient pagan fertility cults, goddess worship was commonly ordered according to a cyclical pattern, corresponding to both the agricultural seasons and a woman’s menstrual cycle.

If this list accurately captures the meaning of masculinity and femininity — in a suggestive rather than exhaustive manner — then it provides us with a coherent and unifying rationale for God’s self-revelation as masculine, Christ’s incarnation as a man, and Scripture’s commands on gender roles. Although gender does not belong to God in an absolute sense (in se), masculinity is nevertheless a more fitting expression of God’s character as understood in relation to creation (ad extra).[45]

Answering Objections

This view of gender is likely to raise objections, two of which I will address here. First, some might object that my definitions of masculinity and femininity are stereotypes, which are based on sweeping generalizations that deny each individual’s uniqueness. Now I recognize that my definitions are generalizations; there are circumstances when it is warranted for men to act in ways typically associated with femininity, and for women to act in ways typically associated with masculinity. That’s why my primary-secondary distinction is important. I would also highlight that not all stereotypes are the same. Some stereotypes are culturally contingent, such as the color blue being associated with boys and pink being associated with girls. Other stereotypes are positively sinful, such as the notion that true manhood is defined by sexual conquest of women. And yet other stereotypes are rooted in universal human nature, transcending historical and cultural boundaries. It is this latter type of stereotyping that I believe characterizes gender, properly understood.

The second possible objection is that this view of gender is demeaning to women, treating them as inferior or less godlike than men. In reply, I would emphasize the importance of grounding our notions of equality in Scripture rather than in contemporary culture. There is a long tradition of Christian reflection on the equality of men and women as divine image-bearers, and it’s worth paying attention to the wisdom of past generations. Francis Turretin defines the image of God as consisting of three parts: human nature (spirituality and immortality of the soul), original righteousness (which was lost in the Fall but restored by grace), and the dominion and immortality of the whole person.[46] With respect to the first and second parts, men and women are the same. With respect to dominion, Turretin writes, “Now it was a dominion common to both (with respect to other creatures) although the man had it peculiarly (because having power over his wife, in which sense the man is called singularly the image of God, 1 Cor. 11:7).”[47]

This is why I described dominion as the end toward which masculinity and femininity are oriented. If we are to honor the inspired and inerrant biblical text, then we have to recognize that men and women stand in different relations to divine dominion: man is “the image and glory of God, but woman is the glory of man” (1 Cor 11:7). And yet this does not make one gender inherently more worthy of dignity or respect than the other. As Petrus Van Mastricht succinctly puts it, “Not only the male bears the image of God, as some wrongly gather from 1 Corinthians 11:7, but also the female, although with respect to his universal dominion, even over the female, the male alone is said by the apostle to be the image of God.”[48]

We intuitively recognize that some people reflect certain divine attributes more directly than do others. An adult reflects divine wisdom more directly than a child. A ruler reflects divine authority more directly than a private citizen. And yet we all share a common essential humanity. In The Four Loves, Lewis distinguishes between two ways of being near to God: nearness of resemblance and nearness of approach.[49] Just because men may more closely resemble God in their masculinity, that does not mean that they have deeper spiritual communion with him. And despite their natural differences, men and women share a common spiritual inheritance in Christ (1 Pet 3:7). They are therefore morally and eschatologically equal.

Conclusion

 There’s a reason why C.S. Lewis purists refuse to follow his publishers’ decision to call his science fiction novels The Space Trilogy. The novels themselves repudiate the very idea of “space.” When Ransom is taken on his first interplanetary voyage, he quickly realizes how mistaken his assumptions had been about outer space:

‘Space’ seemed a blasphemous libel for this empyrean ocean of radiance in which they swam. He could not call it ‘dead’; he felt life pouring into him from it every moment. How indeed should it be otherwise, since out of this ocean the worlds and all their life had come? He had thought it barren: he saw now that it was the womb of worlds, whose blazing and innumerable offspring looked down nightly even upon the earth with so many eyes — and here, with how many more! No: space was the wrong name. Older thinkers had been wiser when they named it simply the heavens — the heavens which declared the glory. . . .[50]

One could justly argue that the modern view of gender, much like the modern view of space, has been sterilized and stripped of its cosmic wonder.[51] We’ve reduced it to a matter of cultural convention or individual expression. Even many Christians struggle to define it beyond simple biological sex or a narrow set of biblically prescribed roles. For Lewis, on the other hand, gender reveals a much deeper reality. It tells us something profound about our very relationship to our Creator, who is so masculine that we are all feminine in relation to him. When we learn to appreciate the full significance of God’s design for gender, we find ourselves in touch with the grand harmonious order of Deep Heaven.

 

[1] C. S. Lewis, Perelandra, in The Space Trilogy (New York, NY: Simon & Schuster, 2011).

[2] Lewis, Perelandra, 172.

[3] Lewis, Perelandra, 171.

[4] Rachel Green Miller, Beyond Authority and Submission: Women and Men in Marriage, Church, and Society (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2019), 148–149.

[5] Lewis, That Hideous Strength, in The Space Trilogy 313. See also Peter Kreeft, “Sexual Symbolism,” https://peterkreeft.com/ topics-more/sexual-symbolism.htm (accessed November 4, 2025): “Male and female are only the biological version of cosmic masculine and feminine.”

[6] For a more thorough critique of the eternal subordination of the Son, see Steven J. Duby, Jesus and the God of Classical Theism (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker, 2022), 76–87, 122–126. To anticipate an objection, I think 1 Corinthians 11:3 is about Christ’s submission to God according to his humanity, not according to his divinity.

[7] Mary Daly, Beyond God the Father (Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 1993), 19.

[8] Sally McFague, Metaphorical Theology: Models of God in Religious Language (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress, 1982); Elizabeth Johnson, She Who Is: The Mystery of God in Feminist Theological Discourse (Redwood City, CA: PublishDrive, 2017).

[9] Rosemary Ruether, Sexism and God Talk: Toward a Feminist Theology (Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 1993); Carol Christ, Rebirth of the Goddess: Finding Meaning in Feminist Spirituality (New York, NY: Routledge, 1998).

[10] Elizabeth Achtemeier, “Exchanging God for ‘No Gods,’” in Alvin Kimel, ed., Speaking the Christian God (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1992); Donald Bloesch, The Battle for the Trinity (Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock, 2001); Alvin Kimel, ed., This Is My Name Forever (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2001).

[11] John W. Cooper, Our Father in Heaven: Christian Faith and Inclusive Language for God (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker, 1998). The CRCNA is a generally more centrist Reformed denomination—more conservative than the mainline RCA, but more progressive than the URCNA. It has permitted the ordination of women to all church offices since 1996. See https://www.crcna.org/welcome/beliefs/position-statements/women-ecclesiastical-office (accessed November 7, 2025).

[12] Cooper, Our Father in Heaven, 92.

[13] Cooper, Our Father in Heaven, 186–187.

[14] On metaphors as improper significations, see Duby, Jesus and the God of Classical Theism, 337–363.

[15] Robert Jenson, “The Father, He . . .” in Kimel, Speaking the Christian God, 104–105, argues that this issue was at the heart of the early Trinitarian controversies: “For the entire joint contention of the variously ‘Arian’ or mediating parties in the great struggle of the fourth century can be summarized thus: ‘Jesus is the Son of the Father’ is a trope. And the entire contention of the Nicene party can be summarized thus: ‘Jesus is the Son of the Father’ is not a trope.”

[16] Cooper’s proposed reasons are the Creator-creature relation (205), the Trinity (213), and the deity of Christ (217). I believe this first reason has merit and return to it below. However, the second and third reasons at best support only the superiority of gendered language for God over gender-egalitarian or gender-neutral language. They do not support the superiority of noninclusive masculine language over noninclusive feminine language, and are therefore vulnerable to the same critiques as those against Peeler below.

[17] Cooper, Our Father in Heaven, 199.

[18] Cooper, Our Father in Heaven, 185.

[19] Cooper, Our Father in Heaven, 261.

[20] Cooper, Our Father in Heaven, 248 n10.

[21] Amy Peeler, Women and the Gender of God (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2022), 115.

[22] Ibid, 137–142.

[23] Fred Sanders, The Deep Things of God, 2nd ed. (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2017), 92. Peeler’s theology echoes that of twentieth-century theologian Wolfhart Pannenberg, who regarded the Trinitarian relations in the economy of redemption as definitive (rather than merely reflective) of the immanent Trinity; see Stephen Holmes, The Quest for the Trinity (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2012), 18; Steven Duby, God in Himself (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2019), 270–279. To be clear, Peeler’s claim is not that the Incarnation constitutes a change in the Trinitarian relations per se, but rather only in their signification. However, this is still unbiblical.

[24] Peeler, 141, believes that Jesus must have had a human mother because “to be a human is to be born, born of a woman.” But why should being born of a woman count as more necessary to humanity than being fertilized from a male sperm? Were not Adam and Eve both human without being born of a woman?

[25] On the significance of such hypothetical reversals of Scripture’s gendered language for God, see C.S. Lewis, “Priestesses in the Church?” in God in the Dock (San Francisco, CA: HarperOne, 2014), 237: “Now it is surely the case that if all these supposals were ever carried into effect we should be embarked on a different religion.”

[26] Of course, this does not mean we can know the rationale behind all of God’s acts, such as his decree to elect some for salvation and to pass over others. His judgments are unsearchable and his ways are inscrutable (Rom. 11:33). And yet it is possible to distinguish between those divine acts that arise solely from God’s will and those that correspond rationally to the created order (see more below).

[27] Kreeft, “Sexual Symbolism.”

[28] Kyle Claunch, “Theological Language and the Fatherhood of God: An Exegetical and Dogmatic Account,” Eikon 5.2 (Fall 2023), 46–77.

[29] James Dolezal, All That Is in God (Grand Rapids, MI: Reformation Heritage Books, 2017), 95–96.

[30] Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I, q. 28, a. 1, ad 3: “There is no real relation in God to the creature; whereas in creatures there is a real relation to God.” Petrus Van Mastricht, Theoretical-Practical Theology, trans. Todd Rester, ed. Joel Beeke (Grand Rapids, MI: Reformation Heritage Books, 2019), 1.2.6.XXIII (2:145–146): “Nor does the relation with what is produced, which from the production belongs to the producer, make that producer a composite. For that relation is not a being of any sort, nor does it imply composition in God (for things are related to something, not in something).”

[31] Claunch, “Theological Language and the Fatherhood of God,” 60: “All scriptural language about God is analogical, but not all analogical language is predicated of God in the same way. Sometimes analogical predicates have their original in God and their analog in creation. This mode of predication is what we are calling proper predication. Other times analogical predicates have their original in creation and their analog in God. This includes many forms of metaphorical speech. This is what we are calling figurative predication.”

[32] Claunch, “Theological Language and the Fatherhood of God,” 71. Claunch also distinguishes between “essential” fatherhood and “personal” fatherhood, the former constituting a relative attribute of the entire Godhead, and the latter specifying the first person of the Trinity.

[33] On the language of “habitude” for God’s relative attributes, see Francis Turretin, Institutes of Elenctic Theology, trans. George M. Giger, ed. James T. Dennison (P&R, 1992), III.IX.XXII (1:201), IV.I.XIII (1:313).

[34] Using Aristotle’s fourfold causality (Physics II.3), we can say that the formal cause of masculinity is the disposition (or habitude), the material cause is the set of qualities comprising the disposition, the efficient cause is the agent who expresses this disposition, and the final cause is dominion.

[35] This also answers Peeler’s objection that those who make gender differences “more poetry than science” (107) are inconsistent in allowing exceptions to gendered behavior patterns but not to formal gender roles. The roles, however, are defined by these primary gender qualities, and without this primary-secondary distinction, nothing would prevent all gender differences from collapsing into relativism.

[36] J. Budziszewski, On the Meaning of Sex (Wilmington, DE: ISI Books, 2014), 61.

[37] Donald Bloesch, Is the Bible Sexist? (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 1982), 70. There are some aspects of Bloesch’s argument with which I would disagree. In addition to his Barthian view of Scripture, he attempts to ground masculinity and femininity in the immanent Trinitarian relations.

[38] Charles Sherlock, The Doctrine of Humanity (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 1997), 197: “If ‘connectedness’ describes women’s experience of embodiment, then ‘externally focused’ is the way I would describe the equivalent male experience.” This also corresponds to the “integration/differentiation” gender trait-pattern difference identified by Stephen Clark, Man and Woman in Christ (Bloomington, IN: Warhorn Media, 2021) 388–398; a woman’s internal orientation tends toward a more integrated psychology, whereas a man’s external orientation tends toward a more differentiated or compartmentalized psychology.

[39] Achtemeier, “Exchanging God for ‘No Gods,’” 8–9; Bloesch, The Battle for the Trinity, 29–41; Cooper, 205; John Frame, The Doctrine of God (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2002), 384. Even Peeler, 114, who stridently denies the connection between divine transcendence and masculinity, concedes this point: “Earlier I noted that God does not create like men conceive, but God’s distinction from creation is aptly pictured in the difference between men and women with regard to pregnancy. God, like a father does, stood distinct from creation and did not carry it within the divine being.”

[40] Clark, Man and Woman in Christ, 398–402.

[41] The connection between masculinity and authority is conspicuously absent in Achtemeier and Cooper’s treatments. Peeler, 106, objects: “Not all the faithful interpret the biblical text to demand that only men should lead. Hence to demand that God’s sovereign initiation be described as masculine is to assume a consensus that does not exist.” But this begs the question: are those who deny men’s leadership really interpreting the biblical text faithfully? By Peeler’s standard of absolute consensus, no single doctrine could ever be established as orthodox, because every doctrine has been challenged by someone at some point in church history.

[42] Frame, Doctrine of God, 384–385. Bloesch, Is the Bible Sexist?, 79: “Patriarchy preserves the biblical principle of an above and a below, of a first and a second, of headship and servanthood.” Kreeft, “Sexual Symbolism”: “God is masculine to everything, from angels to prime matter. That is the ultimate reason why priests, who represent God to us, must be male.”

[43] Katy Faust and Stacy Manning, Them Before Us (Brentwood, TN: Post Hill Press, 2022), 61.

[44] Achtemeier, “Exchanging God for ‘No Gods,’” 11–13.

[45] The language of “fittingness,” “suitability,” and “congruence” is a recurring theme in medieval scholastic treatments on Christ’s incarnation as a man rather than as a woman. See Thomas Aquinas, Commentary on the Sentences of Peter Lombard, III, d. 12, q. 3, a. 1, ad 2: “It should be said that we are not speaking here of God’s power, because he was able to assume any sort of body that he wished. However, we are speaking of fittingness, since Christ came as a teacher and ruler and champion of the human race, which are not things appropriate to a woman. Therefore neither was it appropriate that he assume the female sex.”

[46] Turretin, Institutes, V.X.VI (1:466).

[47] Turretin, Institutes, V.X.XXII (1:469).

[48] Petrus Van Mastricht, Theoretical-Practical Theology, 1.3.9.II (3:251).

[49] Lewis, The Four Loves (San Francisco, CA: HarperOne, 2017), 5–6.

[50] Lewis, Out of the Silent Planet, in The Space Trilogy, 34.

[51] For more on this point, see Joshua Herring, Sons of Adam, Daughters of Eve: C.S. Lewis’s Images of Gender (Davenant Press, 2026), 260–264.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
  • A native of Washington State, Rev. Kyle A. Dillon studied French and History at Seattle Pacific University, then served in the Navy as an Arabic/Kurdish linguist before attending Covenant Theological Seminary in St. Louis. Kyle serves as Assistant Pastor of Theological Instruction at Riveroaks Reformed Presbyterian Church (PCA) in Germantown, Tennessee. He also teaches theology and rhetoric at Westminster Academy in Memphis.

    View all posts

Share This Article

  • green leaf tree under sun set

    The Inevitability of Patriarchy

    By Joe Rigney

  • aerial photography of river between mountains

    A Tale of Two Complementarianisms

    By Doug Ponder

  • a forest filled with lots of tall green trees

    Returning to the Vision of Danvers

    By Denny Burk

View All Articles
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
Click Here Click Here
Malcare WordPress Security