11.20.2026. — Articles

The Delight of Divine Design: Complementarianism and Serious Joy

by Jon Woodyard

Introduction: Recovering the Joy of God’s Design

Much of the modern debate surrounding complementarianism is reactive. Over the last several years, Christians have often found themselves answering objections, clarifying misconceptions,[1] and defending biblical authority against the pressures of an egalitarian moment. This moment arises in a Western culture focused on autonomous “expressive individualism” as the means to freedom and happiness.[2] Much of the work of complementarians, then, has been defensive.

Of course, defense is often necessary. When error arises, Christians counter with the truth of God’s Word. Yet, if all complementarians do is react to error, we run the risk of unintentionally reducing complementarianism to a list of prohibitions: who may preach, who may lead, who may exercise authority.

But complementarianism is not mainly about what one cannot do. Instead, it is a positive vision of God’s good design for men and women. Indeed, what if joy is found in embracing God’s design for humanity instead of stiff-arming it? What if complementarianism is part of God’s original ordering of reality and is structured in such a way to satisfy our longings for true freedom, flourishing, and serious joy?[3] Might we serve the world better if we did more than defend complementarianism and spent time celebrating its goodness?

Therefore, more than mere negative reactions, we need a proactive vision. In addition to a defensive “No,” we need a positive, “Yes!” to God’s good designs for men and women. The point of this essay is to affirm and articulate that God’s complementarian design for men and women is a pathway to man’s delight and God’s glory.   To state it another way in the idiom of John Piper, God is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in him and his design.

In what follows, I’ll attempt to show how a focus on joy in God and his ways demonstrates why explaining, proclaiming, defending, and celebrating complementarianism is necessary work.  Since serious joy and human flourishing are ordinarily found in embracing God and his created designs (Ps 43:4), then God’s complementary design for men and women should be understood as a path to human happiness — lived out at home, in the church, and for the world. Complementarianism, then, should not merely be defended as a good idea; it should be proclaimed as God-glorifying, inherently beautiful, and deeply satisfying. The church’s task is not simply to win an argument about roles and prohibitions, but to display a compelling vision of redeemed masculinity and femininity that leads to seriously joyful men and women.

God’s Design in Nature and Human Flourishing

Any Christian account of nature and human flourishing should begin at creation. In Genesis, before we read of any prohibitions given to Adam and Eve, we find God’s glorious design. From the start, God’s design for manhood and womanhood is profoundly good.[4] Humanity is intentionally created male and female in the image of God (Gen 1:27). Maleness and femaleness are divine designs from a “very good” (Gen 1:31) start. Therefore, the distinction between man and woman, and their complementary designs, belong to that goodness.

Furthermore, in the Genesis narrative we find order and structure. God is Creator. Man and woman are creatures, living in God’s presence and enjoying his rule.[5] This ordered relationship exists within the context of commands and prohibitions (eg., Gen 2:16-17). When the established order fails due to Adam and Eve disobeying God’s word, sin enters the world and chaos ensues (Gen 3). Nature, the way God had established the world, was tossed into disarray. Independence from God’s design led to chaos rather than happiness.

Not only did the first couple usurp the place of God in rejecting his rule for autonomy, they did so via disordered relationships with one another. Adam failed to lead the woman. In his passivity, he stood by while Eve, his “helper,” engaged in conversation with the serpent, took the forbidden fruit, and ate. Adam should have protected his wife and tended the Garden he was commanded to “work” and “keep” (Gen 2:15) by tossing the serpent out. But he failed to lead and, thus, Eve, “usurped Adam’s headship and led the way into sin.”[6] Ever since then, men have embraced passivity or dominance toward their wives while women have longed to usurp the leadership role given to their husbands (Gen 3:16). So, not only do we see disorder in reference to the creatures usurping the place of the Creator, but disorder is evident in the very way man and woman related in the moment, a disorder still at work today.

We intuitively know that ordered living is a good thing. For instance, think about traffic laws. Traffic laws feel like a burden until somebody breaks the rules. Lane markers, stop signs, caution signs, speed limits — none of that exists to infringe on your freedom and fun. Those rules exist to protect. The lines on the highway create the context where you get where you’re going in one piece!

“For you, O LORD, have made me glad by your work; at the works of your hands I sing for joy” (Ps 92:4).

It’s also how God’s commands work. To submit to God’s design is to live within the order of creation so that it may go well with you (cf. Deut 5:33; 6:1–3). To rebel against God’s design is to drive the wrong way on the highway of life. You might get away with it for a while. But reality (and judgment) always catches up.

In short, we are created to exist within a structure, a divinely designed good order. And to be more specific, there’s a complementarian order between man and woman built into creation. The deepest joys we’ll ever know aren’t found in rejecting God’s design — they’re found in receiving it gladly. God’s boundaries were never meant to hold us back. Instead, God’s designs are like road signs, lane markers on the highway leading to flourishing and happiness. Take this order away and you don’t get free flowing traffic. You get traffic jams and car wrecks.

In what follows, we want to briefly show how God’s specific complementarian designs for men and women in the home and at church leads to delight.[7]

Joyful Complementarianism at Home: Sacrificial Leadership and Glad Submission

The home becomes the primary place where biblical manhood and womanhood are displayed. It is in the home where men first take the lead in husbanding and fathering and women follow in glad submission.

First, men have the responsibility to lead in such a way that they point wives and children to Jesus in the gospel. In Ephesians 5, Paul roots marriage not in social categories but in the gospel mystery of Christ and the church. Godly husbands point (imperfectly) to Jesus. They lead like Jesus leads the church. They lay down their lives for their family in such a way they point to the Lamb of God who laid down his life for the Bride (Eph 5:25–26). And when they step up to protect[8] (cf. John 15:13; Col 3:19), they reflect the warrior King who fights and wins our battles. What is more than a godly man who reminds his family of Jesus, their Sovereign, Saving, and Satisfying King?[9]

What a gift it is when human beings, in any organization or institution, find themselves under the steady hand of good leadership. It was, after all, the Queen of Sheba who considered the wise leadership of Solomon and said, “happy are your men” (1 Kings 10:8). When husbands serve their families by exercising strong and sacrificial leadership, even the world may say, “happy is your home.”

Wives, too, play a role in making the home a place of joy.[10] A wife has a unique opportunity to help Christians rejoice in Christ. Through her submission to her husband, she reflects the church’s joyful trust in Christ (Eph 5:22–24; cf. Col 3:18). The church, the blood-bought bride of Jesus, lives and moves and has its being under the Lordship of Christ. Godly wives remind those with eyes to see that there is a happy existence under the authority of another.

When husbands lovingly lead and wives joyfully submit, marriage becomes a living portrait of the gospel. More than that, both husband and wife discover the happiness that comes from living in accordance with God’s good design. God is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in him and his design.

Complementarianism in the Church: The Beauty of Spiritual Fatherhood and Flourishing Service

The church likewise displays the goodness of God’s ordering. Within the church, the structure is fairly simple. There are pastors, deacons, and church members. Complementarians assert that the office of pastor/elder/overseer is reserved for biblically qualified men in accordance with Scripture (1 Tim 2:12–14; 3:1–7).[11] Some complementarians believe women can serve within the diaconate as well, though this is a point of internal debate between complementarians. The membership of the church is open to both men and women equally. Thus, when Paul tells Titus to “put what remained in order” (Titus 1:5), there was an order to be implemented.

The pastoral office especially reflects spiritual fatherhood. Elders are called to protect doctrine, shepherd the flock, exercise sacrificial oversight, and model godliness.[12] This is not because men are inherently more intelligent or spiritually valuable, but because God has created men and women in certain ways to inhabit certain roles in accordance with his good designs.

At the same time, women enrich the church in innumerable ways through discipleship, hospitality, wisdom, counsel, teaching other women and children, missions, mercy ministry, theological insight, prayer, and practical service. A healthy complementarian church does not marginalize women; it honors them by unleashing their indispensable gifts within God’s design for the mission and ministry of the church. Therefore, complementarianism does not minimize women; it situates both men and women within a divinely ordered structure intended for the church’s health and joy.

Indeed, some of the strongest critiques of complementarianism arise not from the doctrine itself but from distorted applications of it. Where men abdicate responsibility, suppress women’s gifts, or confuse leadership with control, biblical complementarianism is betrayed rather than practiced. Just like in the Garden, chaos ensues.

Practically, this plays out in various ways. When elders bear the weight of doctrinal faithfulness and difficult pastoral decisions, women are freed to invest deeply in relationships, discipleship, and mercy ministry without also carrying the burden of final accountability (cf. Heb 13:17). Congregations that actively deploy women’s gifts in appropriate complementary ways[13] tend to be healthier and more relationally rich than either rigid hierarchies or leaderless egalitarian structures.

None of this suggests unhappiness is impossible within complementarian churches and homes, or that happiness is absent elsewhere. Instead, complementarians argue that when God’s design is convictionally embraced and practically implemented — when male leadership is real but not domineering, and female submission is happily received and their contribution is honored rather than minimized — the resulting order tends to produce the kind of relational peace, trust, and flourishing that leads our serious joy and God’s glory.

Conclusion: The Pleasure of Trusting God

To bring this discussion home, remember that what begins in the garden and echoes through the home, the church, and the wider world is not a system of mere prohibitions or a scream of “No!” Instead, complementarianism, rightly understood, is a window into the very character of a God who delights in ordering his creation toward human flourishing rather than chaos.

The world says that freedom means self-rule, that happiness is found in throwing off every boundary and becoming whoever we wish to be or think we can become. But Scripture tells a truer story: that the deepest freedom is found on the other side of surrender, that the lines on the highway are not there to ruin our fun but to help us get home.

Complementarianism, then, is not merely defensible; it is beautiful. It is not merely true; it is good. And a church that recovers this vision will not just win arguments about roles and offices — it will become a living, breathing advertisement for the God who is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in him and in the good world he has made. That is not a diminished vision of manhood and womanhood. That is serious joy.

 

[1] For example, see Denny Burk, Denny Burk, “Mere Complementarianism,” Eikon: A Journal for Biblical Anthropology 1.2 (2019): 28–42; and Denny Burk, “Is Complementarianism a Man-Made Doctrine?,” The Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, June 8, 2021, https://cbmw.org/2021/06/08/is-complementarianism-a-man-made-doctrine-2/;  and Jonathon Woodyard, “Fake News: Complementarianism and Disinformation,” Christ Over All, May 10, 2024, https://christoverall.com/article/concise/encore-fake-news-complementarianism-and-disinformation/.

[2]See Carl Trueman, The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self: Cultural Amnesia, Expressive Individualism, and the Road to Sexual Revolution (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2020).

[3] Throughout this paper, the reader will find the phrase “serious joy” used at various points. It is a phrase borrowed from John Piper and indicates a sense of joy that is not dependent on circumstances, is unshakeably rooted in our God and his designs, and rises above what the New Testament calls light and momentary affliction. For a full explanation, see John Piper, “Serious Joy, Cultural Conflict, and Christian Humility: Thoughts on Christian Education” (message, TCT/BCS Regional Conference, Memphis, November 8, 2019), https://www.desiringgod.org/messages/serious-joy-cultural-conflict-and-christian-humility.

[4] In other words, the opening pages of Genesis do not describe anthropological hierarchy as a necessary evil. Nor does the biblical account give the impression that sexual differentiation is a social construct. See Andrew T. Walker, “Gender and Sexuality,” Concise Theology, The Gospel Coalition, January 15, 2020, https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/essay/gender-and-sexuality/.

[5] For this paradigm of Eden, and God’s Kingdom, see Graeme Goldsworthy, The Goldsworthy Trilogy: Gospel and Kingdom, Gospel and Wisdom, The Gospel in Revelation (Carlisle: Authentic, 2001). I added the idea of “enjoying God’s rule” in an effort to infuse a bit of Christian hedonism.

[6] Raymond C. Ortlund Jr., “Male-Female Equality and Male Headship: Genesis 1–3,” in Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood: A Response to Evangelical Feminism, ed. John Piper and Wayne Grudem (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 1991), 107.

[7] Demonstrating how this design moves beyond the bounds of home and church and into world writ large will have to wait for a future essay.

[8] By “protect,” I have various things in mind. Husbands should protect their wives physically, yes. But there are also ways a husband should protect their wives emotionally, sexually, and spiritually. Tim Challies, “Leadership in the Home—A Godly Man Protects,” Tim Challies (blog), December 3, 2009, https://www.challies.com/christian-living/leadership-in-the-home-a-godly-man-protects/.

[9] This phrase (sovereign, saving, satisfying), is something I have adopted from my friend and mentor, Dr. Jason DeRouchie.

[10] Consider the woman of Proverbs 31. A wife who “does [her husband] good” (31:12); “provides food for her household”  (31:15); “she opens her hand to the poor and reaches out her hands to the needy” (31:20); “opens her mouth with wisdom, and the teaching of kindness is on her tongue” (31:26); indeed, “Her children rise up and call her blessed; her husband also, and he praises her” (31:28). All those things marking the life of a godly woman undoubtedly lead to serious joy within the walls of the home.

[11] Some object to any sort of role differentiation because they assume such ordering communicates lesser value. But that is a non sequitur. It simply does not follow that a different role equals different value. Just like the body has many members, and each member has its part to play, there is one body. Paul writes to Rome and says, “For as in one body we have many members, and the members do not all have the same function, so we, though many, are one body in Christ, and individually members one of another” (Rom 12:4–5). And when he makes the same point to the Corinthian church, he makes it clear that all the parts are important to the whole as he declares, “On the contrary, the parts of the body that seem to be weaker are indispensable” (1 Cor. 12:22).

[12] For the role of elders, see David Mathis, Workers for Your Joy: The Call of Christ on Christian Workers, (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2022).

[13] Complementarians have for years highlighted appropriate roles for women in ministry. For instance, see Wayne Grudem, “But What Should Women Do in the Church?,” Journal for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood 1, no. 2 (November 1995).

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
  • Jonathon D. Woodyard (PhD, Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary) is married to Gina and they have two boys, Calvin and Caleb. He currently serves as the Interim President, Executive Director of the Center for Worldview & Culture, and Assistant Professor of Historical Theology at Southwest Baptist University in Bolivar, MO.

    View all posts

Share This Article

  • aerial photo of green trees

    Four Voices on the Future of Complementarianism

    By Michael Carlino

  • a close up of a green leaf with drops of water on it

    Anthropology, Action, and Attraction: A Constructive Account and Critique of Preston Sprinkle and Gregory Cole’s Position Paper on Same-Sex Attraction

    By Drew Sparks

  • Dead trees in a desert landscape with sand dunes

    Autotalitarianism: the Tyranny of the Self | Editorial

    By Jonathan Swan

View All Articles
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
**Join the Mission**
*Click here for information on how to partner with us to change the world.*
Click Here Click Here
Malcare WordPress Security