
In July of 2026, delegates at the General Assembly of the PCUSA voted overwhelmingly to pass GEN-02, also known as “On Access to Healthcare.”[1] What made this such a significant moment is that the declaration (which passed by a vote of 441-30) states:
Gender affirming care is age-appropriate care that is medically necessary and evidence-based for the well-being of many transgender, nonbinary, and gender-expansive people who experience symptoms of gender dysphoria or distress that result from having one’s gender identity not match their sex assigned at birth.
What is more, the delegates had a vigorous debate over whether it was acceptable for their clergy to be involved in polyamorous relationships. The PCUSA has allowed for the ordination of openly homosexual clergy since 2011. In 2014 the denomination changed its definition of marriage to “two people.” The proposed rule, referred to as CON-10, seeks no change in the denomination’s current policies regarding homosexuality. Rather, it specifically addresses the propriety of polyamorous relationships, arguing that multi-partner sexual relationships create “power imbalances, emotional harm, and spiritual confusion,” particularly for women, children and other marginalized persons.
The rule seeks to forbid clergy from entering a relationship with multiple sexual partners not because such an arrangement is inherently immoral and denies the Scripture’s clear teaching about marriage and physical intimacy. The PCUSA gave up those beliefs years ago. Rather, the rule seeks to forbid the clergy from practicing polyamory because it is believed that such arrangements create “power imbalances.”
The proposal faced vigorous opposition with many arguing in favor of polyamorous relationships for clergy. Indeed, the proposal was voted down and referred back to the presbytery for “further study.”
How does this happen? How does a once orthodox Christian denomination become apostate? Certainly it does not happen overnight. Indeed, the seeds of the downgrade of the PCUSA were planted long ago.
At the risk of oversimplifying, I suggest that the moral collapse of the PCUSA (and the rest of the mainline denominations for that matter) can be traced to two trends.
Missionalism superseded doctrinal clarity.
By “missionalism” I mean the proper impulse to reach people for Christ. The church ought to be zealous to fulfill our Lord’s great commission. However, if the church’s missionalism supersedes a commitment to the unerring Scriptures and a proper concern for the glory of God, then the mission will inevitably become something other than that which our Lord articulated. And, indeed, that is precisely what happened in the PCUSA.
During the 1920s and 30s, the PCUSA was at war with itself. Known as the Fundamentalist-Modernist Controversy, the outcome led to what the PCUSA is today. That is, with the help of moderates and accommodating conservatives, the levers of power were handed to the liberals whose actions would lead to the denomination’s doctrinal downgrade, moral corruption, and massive decline.
Henry Sloan Coffin, a leader among the modernists, followed the example of Friedrich Schleiermacher in believing that doctrine must be judged by one’s own experience. Coffin encouraged his church to “try the doctrine by using it. If it is of no service, let it go. If it opens your eyes, thank God for it.”[2] Coffin did not believe that his subscription to the Westminster Confession of Faith (something required of all PCUSA clergy) bound him to actually accepting the doctrines affirmed in the confession. As was the pattern of all the modernists, “interpretation of the subscription vow obviously gave Coffin a great deal of leeway in accepting the Confession. Unlike Machen, he saw no difficulty in a loose adoption of the creed.”[3]
By the time the Fundamentalist-Modernist Controversy was in full swing, the PCUSA had already lost the plot in terms of the mission to make converts to Christ. Pearl Buck, the famous author and PCUSA missionary to China, had abandoned such essential doctrines as the uniqueness (and perhaps even the historical existence) of Christ, the necessity of conversion, and the atonement.
Robert Speer (1867–1947), a greatly admired and beloved leader in the PCUSA, was for 46 years the Senior Secretary of the Board of Foreign Missions. He was a “personally orthodox man” (Speer contributed two articles to The Fundamentals) who believed the PCUSA should accommodate liberals. The call to win the world for Christ, he frequently argued, must not be hindered by arguments over doctrine. Indeed, he said that the denomination’s liberals were “entitled to be trusted.” His accommodation of liberals extended to the point of allowing them to deny the doctrines of the virgin birth, the atonement, the miracles of Jesus, and his resurrection. To fight them on these matters would only distract from the denomination’s mission to the world. It is a tragic irony that a man so singularly devoted to reaching the world for Christ sowed the seeds of his denomination’s abandonment of that mission.
A desire for unity superseded needed discipline.
The perfected unity of God’s people in the age to come is something for which we long. And yet in this fallen world and in a church that often endures the leaven of error and the incursion of false teachers, separation is at times necessary. Perhaps no two factors tested the unity of the PCUSA more than Harry Emerson Fosdick and the Auburn Affirmation.
Fosdick, famous for his 1922 sermon “Shall the Fundamentalists Win?,” was a liberal Baptist who had been hired by New York’s First Presbyterian Church as their preacher. Not only did Fosdick not affirm the Westminster Confession of Faith, but there did not seem to be a single Christian doctrine which he did not radically alter or dismiss entirely. His weekly presence in the pulpit of First Presbyterian Church was a scandal for many within the PCUSA. And yet the denomination failed repeatedly to discipline the church and the presbytery for fear of schism.
The Auburn Affirmation was a document written in 1924 and signed by over 1,200 PCUSA ministers. It was submitted as a protest against the General Assembly’s action that required all clergy to affirm the so-called five fundamentals: inerrancy of Scripture, Christ’s virgin birth, substitutionary atonement, Christ’s bodily resurrection, and the authenticity of Christ’s miracles. The signers of the Auburn Affirmation argued that insistence of affirmation of those doctrines was schismatic. In typical postmodern fashion, they stated that various “theories” of those doctrines were allowed within their understanding of confessional subscription. They urged the assembly to reject enforcement in order to persevere “freedom” and to avoid neglecting “a world so desperately in need of a united testimony to the gospel.”
But the history of the Mainline denominations has proven that unity cannot be forged across chasms of error. Christian unity is only possible between Christians. And those who deny the most essential claims concerning Christ (his virgin birth, miracles, substitutionary atonement, resurrection, and final judgment) cannot be called Christian in any meaningful sense. Efforts to forge ecclesiastical unity under such terms only ever lower the convictions of conservatives until they become practically indistinguishable from liberals and the denomination enters a death spiral.
By refusing to discipline the New York Presbytery or the signers of the Auburn Affirmation, the message was clear: Denying essential Christian doctrine was not enough to earn a denominational sanction. In the end, both moderates and, ironically, a number of conservatives, frustrated efforts to apply proper ecclesiastical accountability to those who had embraced the very errors which were tearing apart the unity and compromising the mission of the PCUSA.
During his own battle against doctrinal downgrade among Baptists in England, Charles Spurgeon offered this apt illustration:
Some excellent brethren seem to think more of the life than of the truth; for when I warn them that the enemy has poisoned the children’s bread, they answer ‘Dear brother, we are sorry to hear it; and, to counteract the evil, we will open the window, and give the children fresh air.’ Yes, open the window, and give them fresh air, by all means … But, at the same time, this ought you to have done, and not to have left the other undone. Arrest the poisoners, and open the windows, too. While men go on preaching false doctrine, you may talk as much as you will about deepening their spiritual life, but you will fail in it.[4]
Just a few days ago someone forwarded me a video of Sunday services at a PCUSA church. In the video, “Vicar Jenny,” a transgender pastor, used the pulpit to rebuke Jesus for the various things he said which were wrong. Could the moderates and accommodating conservatives of the PCUSA in the 1920s and 30s have envisioned such a travesty? Surely not. They never seem to be able to trace the trajectory of their efforts to link arms with liberals. They believe that their project of minimizing doctrine to just the degree they find acceptable will not succumb to the principle that an object set in motion tends to stay in motion. Meanwhile, their efforts to marginalize those unpleasant gatekeepers like J. Gresham Machen will leave them without a defense against the inevitable downgrade they helped to engineer. One lesson is clear: If you wish to arrest your denomination’s downgrade, do not wait until your transgender clergy are publicly rebuking Jesus from their pulpits.
[1] You can access more details here: https://myga.pc-biz.org/search/3001421.
[2] Bradley J. Longfield, The Presbyterian Controversy (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1991), 90.
[3] Longfield, The Presbyterian Controversy, 86
[4] C.H. Spurgeon, An All Round Ministry (Edinburgh, UK: Banner of Truth, 1973), 374
Share This Article



